In-Situ Stability Control of Energy-Producing Anaerobic Biological
Reactors through Novel Use of Ion Exchange Fibers
Yu Tian, Arup K. SenGupta, and Derick G. Brown*
Department of Civil & Environmental Engineering, Lehigh University, 1 West Packer Avenue, Bethlehem, Pennsylvania 18015,
United States
* S Supporting Information
ABSTRACT: Anaerobic biological treatment of high-strength
organic industrial wastes is preferred over aerobic treatment as
it produces a methane-rich biogas, has much lower energy
requirements, and produces significantly less biosolids. Process
stability and reactor failure are of concern, however, for waste
streams that exhibit large variations in organic loading, which
can cause detrimental pH fluctuations, and that have the
potential for accidental input of toxic metals. Here, we
demonstrate for the first time that the use of ion exchange
fibers (IXFs) can provide passive resilience to these failure
modes, without requiring operator oversight or reactive
process control via chemical addition. IXFs have the advantage
of rapid kinetics due to their small size, and they can be readily
inserted and withdrawn as woven mats or porous pillows. This approach is demonstrated here using the weak-acid IXF FIBAN
X-1 and the strong-base FIBAN A-1. FIBAN X-1 passively stabilized anaerobic reactors by (i) buffering pH fluctuations resulting
from organic overloading due to both an increase in organic concentration and a decrease in hydraulic residence time and (ii)
moderating shock-loads of copper and nickel. FIBAN X-1 also retained ∼95% of its exchange capacity after one year of operation
in anaerobic reactors, demonstrating its long-term performance. In addition, FIBAN A-1 stabilized anaerobic reactors to input of
chromate. These results demonstrate that IXFs can be used to passively stabilize anaerobic biological reactors from upset and
failure and that this technology can be used to enhance energy recovery from high-strength organic waste streams.
KEYWORDS: Anaerobic, Ion exchange fiber, Methane, Metal toxicity, Methanogens, Organic overload
■
INTRODUCTION
High-strength organic waste streams, such as those produced in
agricultural, food-processing, beverage, pharmaceutical, and
chemical industries, contribute to a diverse portfolio of
renewable energy sources. The biological oxygen demand
(BOD) of these organic wastewaters can range from 0.15 to
over 100 g/L (e.g., see the Supporting Information, Table S1).
Aerobic biological processes, with their proven ability to reduce
BOD and their stability to upset, are commonly used to treat
these industrial wastes. This treatment comes at a cost,
however, with significant energy demands for the input of
oxygen into the system and the production of substantial
amounts of biosolids that must be dewatered and disposed. The
use of anaerobic biological processes is particularly attractive for
treatment of these waste streams; as anaerobic systems produce
energy in the form of methane, they have much smaller
operational energy requirements and are typically net energy
positive, and they produce much smaller amounts of biosolids
as compared to aerobic treatment (Figure 1). Anaerobic
reactors also have the advantage that the BOD loading can be
5-10 times greater than that with aerobic reactors, mainly
because of the inherent oxygen transfer limitations in aerobic
systems.
1,2
The trade-off is that anaerobic reactors can be
susceptible to operational failure due to the buildup of volatile
acids, causing acidification and inhibition of methanogenesis,
and the input of toxic chemicals. The key concern here is that
the methanogenic archaea have low cell yields and doubling
times on the order of days, compared to hours typical of
aerobic microorganisms, and this can require a long recovery
time after a failure.
1-3
Active operator oversight and control of
these failure modes must be considered when designing and
operating anaerobic systems.
2,4-14
There are many microbial processes involved in anaerobic
treatment (e.g., Figure S2), and these failure modes mainly
affect the final steps. Here, facultative heterotrophs produce
volatile acids, which are converted to acetic acid by acetogenic
bacteria. The acetic acid is then converted to methane and
carbon dioxide by methanogens. The acid-forming bacteria
have a higher growth rate and wider operational pH range than
the methanogens. When these processes are operating at
steady-state, the rate of organic acid production is balanced by
the uptake rate of the methanogens, and the reactor pH is
Received: July 19, 2017
Revised: September 4, 2017
Published: September 6, 2017
Research Article
pubs.acs.org/journal/ascecg
© XXXX American Chemical Society A DOI: 10.1021/acssuschemeng.7b02435
ACS Sustainable Chem. Eng. XXXX, XXX, XXX-XXX