EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF MEDICAL RESEARCH June 30, 2003
Abstract: In males inguinal hernia and varicocele
are frequent diseases with a reported incidence of
1-2 % for hernia (Klinge 2000) and up to 20 %
(Mickevicius et al. 2002) for varicocele. In 1997
approximately 220,000 inguinal herniotomies
were performed in Germany (Horeyseck 1997).
Leading symptoms in both diseases are complaints
and dragging pain in the inguinal region radiating
into the testis. Surgeons treat traditionally ingui-
nal hernia whereas varicocele is the domain of
urologists. Coincident appearance of inguinal her-
nia and varicocele is expected to be more frequent
with regard to the pathogenesis (Friedman et al.
1993; Nakada et al. 1994; Rosch et al. 2002;
Rovsing 1916; Santoro et al. 2000; Wagh and Read
1972). Therefore both surgeon and urologist
should see patients with inguinal hernia or varico-
cele.
If patients with hernia repair postoperatively
suffer from similar complaints again, it should
not be interpreted rashly as mesh complication
(Conze et al. 2001). The need for an improved as-
sessment has been recognized (Kehlet et al. 2002).
It sounds reasonable to assume, that quite a num-
ber of patients with complaints after successful
hernia repair may suffer from an undiagnosed va-
ricocele.
We present a case of inguinal hernia with mesh
implantation and concomitant varicocele as an ex-
ample for mesh-unrelated postherniorrhaphy
pain.
Key words: Inguinal hernia; varicocele; mesh;
Lichtenstein procedure; postherniorrhaphy pain
CASE REPORT
A 34 years old male presents with the typical
symptoms of an acute left inguinal hernia.
Intraoperative diagnosis consists of a direct hernia
with defect of the posterior wall (Nyhus IIIa); an
indirect hernia is excluded. The patient is treated
according to the Lichtenstein procedure with
mesh (VYPRO II, Ethicon Hamburg, Germany)
under general anaesthesia. He receives one shot
antibiotic prophylaxis (cephazolin 2g) and postop-
eratively diclophenac 100 mg for 3 days for pain
relief. The weeks after the operation neither intra-
operative nor postoperative complications nor
complaints about pain were reported. 5 months
later the patient presents with complains in the
left inguinal region, especially during sexual activ-
ity. After exclusion of a recurrent hernia or a
mesh complication - e.g. inflammation, infection
or dislocation - the patient is sent to the urologist
for further evaluation. Palpation and inspection
reveals no abnormalities of testis and spermatic
cord; sonography of the left testis and epididymis
shows a homogenic echo of the parenchyma.
Duplexsonography excludes any damage to the
vascular structure of spermatic cord and testis. At
last during valsalva manoeuvre a significant reflux
of the testicular vein into the enlarged veins of the
plexus pampiniformis, typical for a varicocele, is
demonstrated. The urologist recommends sclero-
therapy of the varicocele.
DISCUSSION
Inguinal hernia is a frequent illness of the male
(Klinge 2000). The incidence of male inguinal her-
nia in Great Britain is 2 % and in females 0.3 %
(Keith 1923). In 1997 approximately 220.000 in-
guinal herniotomies were performed in Germany
(Horeyseck 1997). Chronic pain of patients after
herniotomy is often considered to be caused by
intra-operative injury to the inguinal nerves
(Kehlet et al. 2002) or mesh complication (Conze
et al. 2001); however, other factors, e.g., concomi-
tant and previously asymptomatic varicocele, may
be involved when recurrence or mesh complica-
tion has been excluded as in our case. Others have
found no evidence that mesh influences sexual
function or testicular perfusion (Zieren et al.
2001). Varicocele, an abnormal enlargement of the
veins of the plexus pampiniformis of the spermat-
ic cord, was observed in 1-2% of males in older re-
ports (Rovsing 1916). According to newer obser-
vations there may be an incidence of up to 20 % in
young males (Mickevicius et al. 2002). There are
no scientific reports available on the incidence of
inguinal hernia and concomitant varicocele. The
frequency and pathogenesis of both diseases in
males may lead to the assumption that this coinci-
254
Eur J Med Res (2003) 8: 254-256
©
I. Holzapfel Publishers 2003
Case report
I NGUINAL HERNIA AND CONCOMITANT VARICOCELE
MIMICKING MESH COMPLICATION
R. G. Holzheimer
1
, A. Schreiber
2
1
Center for Short Stay Surgery, Munich Sauerlach / Department of Surgery, Martin-Luther Universität Halle-Wittenberg,
2
Department of Urology, Krankenhaus Barmherzige Brüder, Munich, Germany