Page 1 of 3
A New Non-Surgical Alternative to Manipulations
Under Anesthesia Following Knee Replacement
D Carl Freeman
1
* and Robert J Ference
2
1
Department of Biological Sciences, Wayne State University, USA
2
DMC Harper University Hospital, USA
Introduction
Arthrofibrosis of the knee, stiff knee, is a common complication
of knee surgery, with an incidence rate of 2% to 23% [1]. Stiff
knee is usually defined as an inability to flex the knee to 90° [2].
Risk factors for stiff knee include being African American, female,
less than 60 years old, nicotine use [3] and multiple surgeries [4].
LaHaise et al. [5] report that discharge range of motion (ROM) is
a reliable predictor of stiff knee. However, they also report that
BMI is negatively related to the frequency of stiff knee. Whereas
Gadinsk et al. [6] report that BMI is strongly positively related to
the frequency of stiff knee. These conflicting results suggest there
is the possibility of confounding factors involved and that very large
sample sizes will be needed to resolve the issue. Recently, Arshi
et al. [7] report that patients undergoing outpatient total knee
arthroplasty are 28% more likely to have a stiff knee than patients
undergoing inpatient knee arthroplasty. Interestingly, Pamilo et al.
[8] found that fast-tracked TKA patients did not have an increase
in stiff knee (manipulation under anesthesia) rates compared to
inpatient total knee replacements.
Treatment options available for treating stiff knee, range
from physical therapy, manipulation under anesthesia (MUA),
arthroscopic lysis, to open lysis, with MUA having the largest gains
in ROM [2], especially when performed early and open lysis having
the least gain in ROM [2]. MUA is the most common treatment
for stiff knee [2,3] and is usually recommended if patients have
not achieved 90° of flexion, though the time span for making the
assessment ranges from two weeks to over three months post-
surgery [2]. Typically, MUAs resulted in patients having 101° of
flexion, if performed after six weeks post-surgery [1,4] However
Newman et al.4 found that for MUAs performed before six weeks
the patients achieved 106.7° ROM. Nevertheless, the average of
ROMs failed to reach the 110° of flexion required to perform most
activities of daily living [9]. Desai et al. [10], found that 24% of their
patients required a second MUA, unfortunately these second MUAs
did not lead to gains in ROM.
Our purpose here is to introduce the new non-surgical, low pain
alternative to MUAs, the in home X10 knee rehabilitation machine
(Figure 1). This computer-controlled device has a robotic arm
that is moved by pressure to incrementally increase the range of
motion. Once the patient has established their maximum pressure
threshold, the machine will use that amount of force to move the
patient’s leg (controllable to within one pound of pressure and one
degree of flexion). However, as the session progresses the pressure
needed to reach a given degree of flexion declines, enabling the
patient to increase their flexion and then gradually increase the
*Corresponding author : D. Carl Freeman, Department of Biological Sciences, Wayne
State University, Detroit MI 48202, USA.
Received Date: November 28, 2019
Published Date: December 05, 2019
ISSN: 2687-816X DOI: 10.33552/GJOR.2019.02.000528
Global Journal of
Orthopedics Research
Research Protocol Copyright © All rights are reserved by D. Carl Freeman
This work is licensed under Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License GJOR.MS.ID.000529.
Abstract
Stiff knee occurs in between 2% and 23% of total knee arthroplasty patients. Resolution of a stiff knee is critical for patients’ quality of life
following a TKA. Historically, treatment options include physical therapy, manipulation under anesthesia, arthroscopic lysis, and open lysis. Excluding
physical therapy, the other options all require anesthesia, with procedures usually being done in a hospital or surgical center. Here, we report on a
new non-surgical alternative that is done in patients’ homes and is as efficacious as a manipulation under anesthesia.
Keywords: Stiff knee; Manipulation under anesthesia; X10; Total knee arthroplasty; Flexion