NATURE REVIEWS | RHEUMATOLOGY ADVANCE ONLINE PUBLICATION | 1
Division of
Rheumatology, Beth
Israel Deaconess
Medical Centre,
Harvard Medical
School, 330 Brookline
Avenue, Dana 517‑C,
Boston, MA 02215,
USA (J. C. Crispín,
C. M. Hedrich,
G. C. Tsokos).
Correspondence to:
J. C. Crispín
jcrispin@
bidmc.harvard.edu
Gene-function studies in systemic
lupus erythematosus
José C. Crispín, Christian M. Hedrich and George C. Tsokos
Abstract | The aetiology of systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) is complex and is known to involve both genetic
and environmental factors. In a small number of patients, single‑gene defects can lead to the development
of SLE. Such genes include those encoding early components of the complement cascade and the 3'–5'
DNA exonuclease TREX1. In addition, genome‑wide association studies have identified single‑nucleotide
polymorphisms that confer some susceptibility to SLE. In this Review, we discuss selected examples of genes
whose products have distinctly altered function in SLE and contribute to the pathogenic process. Specifically,
we focus on the genes encoding integrin αM (ITGAM), IgG Fc receptors, sialic acid O‑acetyl esterase (SIAE),
the catalytic subunit of protein phosphatase PP2A (PPP2CA) and signalling lymphocytic activation molecule
(SLAM) family members. Moreover, we highlight the changes in epigenetic signatures that occur in SLE.
Such epigenetic modifications, which are abundantly present and might alter gene expression in the presence
or absence of susceptibility variants, should be carefully considered when deconstructing the contribution
of individual genes to the complex pathogenesis of SLE.
Crispín, J. C. et al. Nat. Rev. Rheumatol. advance online publication 4 June 2013; doi:10.1038/nrrheum.2013.78
Introduction
Early and recent genetic studies have established that
autoimmunity is associated with heritable traits and
that predisposition to autoimmunity is, at least in part,
genetically determined.
1
Accordingly, autoimmune
disorders commonly cluster among first-degree rela-
tives.
2
However, the fact that the clinical concord-
ance among monozygotic twins is <50% in systemic
lupus erythematosus (SLE)
3
indicates that additional
factors make a substantial contribution towards the
development of this disease.
The immune system is comprised of an extensive array
of cellular and molecular elements that must discern
between self and nonself molecules and mount responses
tailored to fit a huge variety of antigens. Individual
genetic variation appears to affect various phases of the
immune response, ranging from foreign or self antigen
recognition to the final effector phases. However, the
mechanisms by which heritable traits determine pro-
tection or susceptibility to autoimmunity are currently
poorly understood.
Furthermore, the immune system is extremely
plastic and continuously reshapes itself in an attempt
to increase its affinity for antigens by changing its rep-
ertoire and modifying its receptors. This plasticity is
accomplished by complex regulatory changes in gene
expression that include ‘silencing’ or ‘opening’ of genetic
loci and even the mutation of germline DNA (as in the
case of immunoglobulin somatic hypermutation). This
fundamental aspect of the immune system must be
considered in conceptual models intended to link heredi-
tary factors to disease pathogenesis. Genetic variation
represents only the starting point, and its influence is
gradually and differentially modified by several layers of
nonhereditary factors.
Genome-wide association studies (GWAS) have iden-
tified a fairly large number of genes associated with
SLE.
4–6
A substantial effort is underway to determine
how SLE-associated variants contribute to the risk of SLE
development, and the current working models have been
described in detail elsewhere.
7,8
In this Review, we discuss
pathways through which selected genes contribute to the
initiation and propagation of the autoimmune response
and the development of organ damage in patients with
SLE. We have chosen to focus on a small number of genes
that encode proteins whose expression levels and/or
functions are abnormal in patients with SLE but that
have not been extensively reviewed elsewhere. Some of
these genes have not been detected by GWAS; this might
be because of technical limitations or, more impor-
tantly, because genetic variation is not what links them
to SLE but rather the fact that their expression is con-
trolled by other SLE-associated factors, such as particular
epigenetic changes or cellular events (for example, those
associated with chronic immune activation).
SNPs and copy number variations
Approximately 35 genes have been associated with SLE
through GWAS.
9
These associations are established when
a given genetic marker (usually a single-nucleotide poly-
morphism [SNP]) is found more frequently in patients
with SLE than in matched healthy controls. In rare cases,
Competing interests
The authors declare no competing interests.
REVIEWS
© 2013 Macmillan Publishers Limited. All rights reserved