Role of Scrap Recycling for CO
2
Emission Reduction
in Steel Plant: A Model Based Approach
Manisha Sahoo, Sidhartha Sarkar, Ajoy C. R. Das, Gour Gopal Roy,
and Prodip Kumar Sen*
Scrap recycling in steel industry plays a crucial role in green technology
development by reducing CO
2
emissions. Plant scale predictions on
effectiveness of steel scrap recycle have been rarely attempted. A life cycle
inventory (LCI)-based methodology for plant CO
2
emissions is developed
using process modeling of different primary stages (blast furnace-basic
oxygen process (BF-BOF) and directly reduced iron (DRI, coal based) -
electric arc furnace (EAF) process with scrap additions). Emission data from
primary stages is used for secondary processing stages for predicting the
scope of further reduction. Plant emission reduction through scrap recycle
has shown that primary stage emission values can decrease to 1.79 kg
CO
2
/FU (functional unit) and 2.30 kg CO
2
/FU, respectively, for BF-BOF and
DRI-EAF routes, by using 400–420 kg scrap per ton of crude steel. The
DRI-EAF route emissions can further decrease if gas-based DRI is used.
Secondary processing of scrap has the potential to decrease overall steel
industry emissions to 1.16 kg CO
2
/FU. Specific country-based data is
processed to estimate net emissions with scrap addition to both primary
and secondary stages leading to net emissions of 2.17 kg CO
2
/FU from
2.6 kg CO
2
/FU without scrap addition.
1. Introduction
Over the past few decades, there has been an increasing demand
for steel due to development in building, construction, and
transportation. Several forecasts indicate that the world’s steel
consumption will increase by the order of 2500 million tonnes
up to the year 2050.
[1]
The steel industry generates between 7 and
9% of direct emissions from the global use of fossil fuel.
[2]
In the
industry sector, the iron and steel sector has the second-largest
energy consumption of all industrial sectors (after chemicals and
petrochemicals), accounting for 22% of total industrial energy
use and 31% of industrial direct CO
2
emissions in 2012.
[3]
Reducing greenhouse
gas emissions is a global challenge for the
steel industry that requires a global solu-
tion. Besides improvement of energy
efficiency in primary production of steel,
promoting recycling of steel scrap has
prominently featured for reducing CO
2
emissions and driving the steel industry
toward circular economy. Statistical data on
scrap recycling rates is available for several
countries in the literature
[4–7]
from which it
can be observed that the global recycle
content of steel from scrap is not high
(35–36%). The necessity of increasing
recycle content for enhancing steel indus-
try sustainability has been stressed by
World Steel Association.
[2,8]
Possible scenarios on scrap availability
and utilization has been the subject of
various publications which describe poten-
tial techniques available for predictions,
such as multi recycling approach, product
environmental footprint and mass flow
analysis.
[9,10]
For predictions of mitigation
of CO
2
emissions,
[10]
energy saving potential data base and
emission factors have been used on a sectoral basis without
supporting process models, but using IPCC database for
emission factors. Such studies and other similar studies
[11,12]
lead to sector-based information on CO
2
mitigation which are
often country specific. Plant scale predictions on use of scraps for
emission reduction have been rarely attempted. The potential of
scrap use for emission reduction purposes for a given plant
configuration require use of relevant process models for the
plant. Such predictions are likely to promote use of scraps for a
given plant configuration. This in turn influences the sectoral
average for emission reduction through use of scraps. Life cycle
inventory (LCI) for CO
2
emissions has been worked out based on
use of process models, primary/secondary processing with/
without scrap, as discussed subsequently in a later section.
[8,13–
17]
Emission reduction is also promoted by diffusion of energy
efficient technologies coupled with scrap availability based on
various governmental panel information,
[7,11,12]
although model-
based comparative assessment of use of scrap vis-à-vis use of
energy efficient technology has not been made at plant scale. The
current paper attempts to examine the aspect of emission
reduction through scrap recycle in a plant which requires
process modelling of different steps to assess the possible
M. Sahoo, Prof. P. K. Sen, Prof. G. G. Roy
Department of Metallurgical and Materials Engineering
IIT Kharagpur, West Bengal 721302, India
S. Sarkar
Flat 1406, Tapti Tower, Godrej Prakriti
Barrackpore Trunk Road, Sodepur, Kolkata, West Bengal 700115, India
A. C. R. Das
Ministry of Steel
Government of India
House No A 38, Ramprastha, Ghaziabad, Uttar Pradesh 201011, India
E-mail: prodipksen@outlook.com
DOI: 10.1002/srin.201900034
www.steel-research.de
FULL PAPER
steel research int. 2019, 1900034 © 2019 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim 1900034 (1 of 11)