Understanding the contributions
of some Russian scientists to
developing systems thinking and
the theory of evolution
Tatiana A. Medvedeva
Department of World Economy and Law, Siberian State Transport University,
Novosibirsk, Russian Federation
Abstract
Purpose – This study aims to explain and illustrate the character of Russian systems thinking and to show
how it is different and similar to traditions in the West. This study’s second aim is to describe the
contributions of some Russian scientists to developing systems thinking and the theory of evolution. This
study introduces the predecessors of Charles Darwin in Russia, both supporters and critics of his ideas, as
well as scientists who have made similar contributions to the development of systems thinking, particularly
Vladimir Vernadsky and Alexander Bogdanov.
Design/methodology/approach – Philosophical and theoretical comparisons. In the Russian
intellectual tradition, the terms “Russia” and the “West” are likely codes for signifying fundamental
philosophical questions about the universality of thinking and culture. The term “West” means universal,
rational truth without taking into consideration any differences in life and cultural practice. The term
“Russia” means impossibility of such a universal truth and a necessity to look for solutions on the level of life,
not only on the level of rational thinking.
Findings – Paying attention to differences in approaches to systems and cybernetics and the theory of
evolution will enrich the further development of systems sciences in Russia and the West. The paper
examines the philosophical underpinnings of science rather than just testing or extending an existing theory.
The result is better mutual understanding among scientists with different backgrounds.
Originality/value – This study suggests new avenues for research and expands the range of conceptual
possibilities. It improves mutual understanding among scholars and countries. Also, it adds to the topics
discussed within the field of systems and cybernetics and the theory of evolution.
Keywords Intellectual traditions, Theory of evolution, Tektology, Systems thinking, Cybernetics
Paper type Conceptual paper
Introduction
Scientists learn about the world using scientific methods. The procedures used by scientists
for constructing and testing descriptions of observations are implemented in a certain
logical approach in a particular intellectual tradition. The apparatus of logical thinking is
based on a set of categories, assumptions and rules for formulating problems and
constructing evidence in each field of knowledge. Knowing the logical apparatus, it is
possible to solve certain problems. But over time, new tasks appear that cannot be solved
within the framework of the old logical constructions, and possibly, within the framework of
the earlier intellectual tradition.
As human society develops and interactions intensify, it is becoming necessary to
coordinate the activities of people living not only in different countries, but also on different
continents. There are questions and problems requiring the collective efforts of the peoples
Contributions
of some
Russian
scientists
Received 17 March 2019
Revised 3 December 2019
30 March 2020
3 April 2020
Accepted 3 April 2020
Kybernetes
© Emerald Publishing Limited
0368-492X
DOI 10.1108/K-03-2019-0175
The current issue and full text archive of this journal is available on Emerald Insight at:
https://www.emerald.com/insight/0368-492X.htm