Performance of Space-Frequency Codes in
MIMO Channels with Frequency Offset
Dung Ngoc Dao and Chintha Tellambura
Electrical and Computer Engineering, University of Alberta
Edmonton, Alberta T6G 2V4, Canada
Email: {dndung, chintha}@ece.ualberta.ca
Telephone: (1-780) 492 7228, Fax: (1-780) 492 1811
Abstract—We investigate the pair-wise error probability (PEP)
performance of space-frequency (SF) codes over quasi-static,
frequency-selective Rayleigh fading channels with frequency
offset (FO). The PEP expression shows that the conventional
SF code design criteria are remained valid. If the normalized
FO (NFO) is less than 1%, the performance loss is negligible.
The loss increases with FO and with signal to noise ratio (SNR).
We show that diversity can be used to mitigate the effects of
FO. However, with large FO, the PEP is no longer exponentially
decays with SNR. Therefore, we propose a SF coding scheme to
combat effectively with even very high NFO (20%). Simulation
results confirm our theoretical evaluations.
I. I NTRODUCTION
The space time (ST) codes proposed by Tarokh et al. [1]
for coherent systems over quasi-static flat fading channels
achieves the maximum diversity order (DO) d = MN , where
M and N are the number of Tx (Tx) and Rx (Rx) antennas.
The ST codes can achieve at least the designed DO in the
FSF channels [1], but are not guaranteed to exploit all the
available frequency diversity advantage of FSF channels. To
overcome this, the authors in [2], [3], [4] and references
therein propose new ST coding methods so that the maximum
achievable DO is obtainable. It is found that in FSF channels,
the maximum DO is d = LMN where L is the number of
paths of channels. There are two approaches to design codes
that can achieve this maximum DO [5]. In the first method,
ST codes are constructed in the time domain, whereas in the
second method called space-frequency (SF) coding, the source
symbols are encoded across the subcarriers (or sub-carriers) of
orthogonal frequency division multiplexing (OFDM) symbols
in the frequency domain. Su et al. [6] derive SF code criteria
which show an explicit relation between the SF code matrix
and the characteristic parameters of FSF fading channels such
as path delays and delay power distribution.
Like other error control coding methods, the performance
of SF codes depends on the propagation environment [7].
Moreover, the performance of SF codes and OFDM may
be affected by underlying factors such as frequency offset
(FO), timing error, to name a few. A residual FO exists
due to carrier synchronization mismatch and Doppler shift
[8]. Residual FO breaks down the orthogonality among sub-
carriers, hence inter-carrier interference (ICI) is produced and
bit error rate (BER) is increased consequently. Several papers
have analyzed the effects of FO on the BER performance. For
example in [9], BER is calculated for single input single output
(SISO) OFDM systems with various modulation schemes. The
authors in [10], [11] provide BER expressions of MIMO-
OFDM employing Alamouti’s scheme [12]. However, to the
best of our knowledge, the impact of FO on the SF code design
criteria and the performance have not been investigated. This
interesting question will be addressed in our paper.
We analytically show that the SF code design criteria still
hold in the case of FO. The performance loss is negligible
if the NFO is small. This loss is increased rapidly with the
increase of NFO and with signal-to-noise ratio (SNR). When
NFO is large, PEP performance of SF codes no longer decays
exponentially. To mitigate the effect of FO, we generalize the
work of [13] for MIMO-OFDM with SF codes. The resulting
SF codes not only achieve the same diversity and coding gains
as the SF codes derived in [6] but also are capable of ICI
self-cancellation. Simulations have showed that the ICI self-
cancellation SF codes still yields good performance when the
FO is extremely high, about 20%.
The paper has seven sections. The model of MIMO-OFDM
systems with FO is presented in Section II. Section III reviews
the design criteria of SFC codes. In Section IV, we derive
the PEP performance of SF codes in the presence of FO.
In Section V, we propose a class of SF codes that reduce
effectively FO effects to PEP. Section VI provides simulation
results to support the theoretical analysis. We summarize the
paper in Section VII.
II. FREQUENCY OFFSET IN OFDM SYSTEMS
This section briefly introduces the OFDM system with FO
model to be analyzed for remaining parts of the paper.
A. MIMO-OFDM System Model
We consider the MIMO-OFDM system with M Tx and
N Rx antennas. The number of subcarriers in the OFDM
modulator is K. The L−path quasi-static Rayleigh fading
channel model is assumed identically for any link between Tx
antenna m (m =1, ..., M ) and Rx antenna n (n =1, ..., N ).
The channel impulse response in the time domain is [14]
h
m,n
(t, τ )=
L−1
l=0
α
m,n
(t, l)δ(τ − τ
l
) (1)
702 0-7803-8622-1/04/$20.00 ©2004 IEEE
Authorized licensed use limited to: UNIVERSITY OF ALBERTA. Downloaded on December 22, 2009 at 16:14 from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.