RESEARCH ARTICLE
Optimum composition ratios of multicomponent mixtures
of organic Rankine cycle for engine waste heat recovery
Min-Hsiung Yang
1
| Rong-Hua Yeh
2
1
Department of Naval Architecture and
Ocean Engineering, National Kaohsiung
University of Science and Technology,
Taiwan, ROC
2
Department of Marine Engineering,
National Kaohsiung University of Science
and Technology, Taiwan, ROC
Correspondence
Rong-Hua Yeh, Department of Marine
Engineering, National Kaohsiung
University of Science and Technology,
No. 142, Haijhuan Road, Nanzih District,
Kaohsiung City 81157, Taiwan, ROC.
Email: rhyeh@nkust.edu.tw
Funding information
Ministry of Science and Technology,
Grant/Award Number: MOST 108-2221-E-
992 -024 -MY2
Summary
With the temperature glide in saturation states, the mixture working fluids
have the advantages in thermal energy conversion. In this study, through the
investigation in optimum mass fractions of multicomponent mixture working
fluids, the economic performance enhancement of the organic Rankine cycle
system is obtained for recovering waste heat from engine. The zero ozone-
depletion-potential and dry working fluids of R236fa, R245fa, and R1336mzz
(Z) are selected as the components of multicomponent mixtures in the system.
The net power output, heat transfer calculation, and apparatus cost evaluation
are employed to evaluate the power cost of the organic Rankine cycle system.
Parameters of temperatures of waste heat sources and efficiencies of expanders
are taken into account. The comparisons of economic performances for single-
component working fluid and multicomponent mixtures with optimum mass
fractions are proposed. The results show that R245fa, having a levelized cost of
energy, LCOE, of 8.75 × 10
-2
$/kW-h, performs the best for single-component
working fluids, better than R236fa by 1.6% and R1336mzz(Z) by 8.3%. All the
two-component mixtures are superior to their single-component working
fluids in economic performance. Among the three two-component mixture
working fluids, R1336mzz(Z)/R236fa has the lowest LCOE
min
, 8.57 × 10
-2
$/kW-h, followed by R236fa/R245fa and R245fa/R1336mzz(Z). In addition,
R236fa/R245fa/R1336mzz(Z) mixture, which has a LCOE
min
of 8.47 × 10
-2
$/kW-h, economically outperforms all other working fluids and has a lower
LCOE
min
than R236fa/R245fa by 1.7% and R245fa/R1336mzz(Z) by 2%.
KEYWORDS
composition ratio, economic performance, multicomponent mixture, organic rankine cycle,
working fluid
1 | INTRODUCTION
Lately, engine waste heat recovery (WHR) has attracted
more and more attentions since it can both improve the
thermal efficiencies of engines and help vehicles and ves-
sels meet the worldwide restrictions of CO
2
emissions.
For large diesel engines in merchant ships, the exhaust
gas, cylinder cooling water, and scavenge air cooling
water may serve as the waste heat sources. Owing to the
low boiling temperature of working fluid, the organic
Rankine cycle (ORC) system possesses a great potential
in conversion of these waste heat energies into electricity.
To recover the waste heat from the internal combustion
engine, Vaja and Gambarotta
1
considered three different
Received: 5 July 2019 Revised: 14 October 2019 Accepted: 17 October 2019
DOI: 10.1002/er.4977
Int J Energy Res. 2019;1–19. wileyonlinelibrary.com/journal/er © 2019 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. 1