Structural and Multidisciplinary Optimization
https://doi.org/10.1007/s00158-020-02714-0
RESEARCH PAPER
Optimization of beam profiles for improved piezoelectric energy
harvesting efficiency
C. Volkan Karadag
1
· Seyda Ertarla
1
· Nezih Topaloglu
1
· A. Fethi Okyar
1
Received: 2 April 2020 / Revised: 11 July 2020 / Accepted: 5 August 2020
© Springer-Verlag GmbH Germany, part of Springer Nature 2020
Abstract
Piezoelectric cantilever beams are among the most popular vibration energy harvesting devices. Homogenization of the
spatial distribution of axial strain along those beams increases harvesting efficiency. The general approach to minimize axial
strain variation is to use triangular or trapezoidal width profiles. In this study, a width profile function that includes curved
shapes is proposed and a finite element–based optimization scheme is constructed to maximize harvesting efficiency. A
distribution parameter is defined for quantifying the strain uniformity. Optimization is performed for various tip mass values,
using this parameter as the objective function. It is shown that curved beam profiles exhibit less variation in axial strain,
compared to triangular and rectangular beams. Optimized shapes for minimal strain variation at resonance are determined.
Experimental results also validate the findings of the optimization. At least 22% increase in strain uniformity is obtained
with the optimized-shaped beam, compared to a triangular beam when no tip mass is used. The increase in strain uniformity
becomes 29% when the tip mass is increased to 5 g. The results indicate the potential of employing beam-type piezoelectric
energy harvesters with optimized width profiles.
Keywords Shape optimization · Vibration energy harvesting · Finite element method · Piezoelectric energy harvesting ·
Deflection measurement
1 Introduction
Research on vibration energy harvesting has increased in
recent years. Applications of vibration energy harvesters
(VEH) hold up as wireless sensor networks, body sensor
networks, and portable electronic devices for today and
future (Senthilkumar et al. 2019). Electromagnetism (Foisal
et al. 2012), electrostatics (Lee et al. 2009), and piezo-
electricity (Karadag and Topaloglu 2016; Pasharavesh et
al. 2017) are three common methods that generate energy
from vibration. Among vibration energy harvesting meth-
ods, piezoelectric cantilever beam–based energy harvesting
is a common and effective approach.
Responsible Editor: Byeng D Youn
This research has been funded by TUBITAK (The Scientific
and Technological Research Council of Turkey) under Grant No.
117M101.
Nezih Topaloglu
nezih.topaloglu@yeditepe.edu.tr
1
Yeditepe University, Faculty of Engineering, Atasehir,
34755, Istanbul, Turkey
Optimization of the performance of vibration energy har-
vesters has been a major topic of research. As an example,
a robust genetic algorithm–based optimization that maxi-
mizes the power transmissibility and bandwidth of a bistable
electromagnetic energy harvester (Yang and Zhou 2019)
was presented. The effects of parameter uncertainties were
considered, and an experimental verification was given. Dai
and Harne (2018) assessed the effect of harmonic base exci-
tation frequency, stiffness nonlinearity, and stochastic base
excitation on output electrical power and determined the
optimal load resistance resulting in maximum output power.
Cai and Harne (2019a) constructed an analytical model of
a piezoelectric energy harvester with power conditioning
circuitry. The influence of output impedance, excitation fre-
quency, and the duty cycle of the buck-boost converter was
analyzed, and the optimal duty cycle for maximum DC
power delivery was obtained. Franco and Varoto (2017)
employed sequential quadratic planning and found the opti-
mal beam length, piezo-layer length, tip mass height, and
load resistance that maximizes the output voltage and power
within a predefined excitation frequency range. The effect
of parameter uncertainties was also investigated by intro-
ducing random perturbations in the optimal parameters and