282 book reviews
Asian Review of World Histories
Published with license by Koninklijke Brill NV | doi:10.1163/22879811-12340131
© Alisher Khaliyarov, 2023 | ISSN: 2287-965X (print) 2287-9811 (online)
Jagjeet Lally, India and the Silk Roads: The History of a Trading World. Noida, India:
HarperCollins, 2021. xv+415 pages. ISBN: 9789354227240 (HB ).
The Silk Road’s many leagues of extent and many centuries of existence have
made it one of the most studied topics in Eurasian history. In recent years,
scholars have written and published many revisionist studies dedicated to the
decline of the Silk Road trade after the Age of Explorations; in comparison, the
study of trade between Central and South Asia during more recent centuries
still suffers from lack of research. Professor Lally’s book on India and the Silk
Roads is a great contribution toward understanding this neglected period of
history in Eurasia. Built on the pioneering studies of Stephan Dale and Scott
Levi, Lally expands our knowledge by exploring the increasing complexity and
sophistication of caravan trade between Central and South Asia during the era
of “imperial transition.” The author places the caravan trade at the center of
the story, but expands the story’s scale by looking at bazaars and caravanserais,
as well as the stories of peasants and middlemen, goods of exchange, and the
people in power of the trade. The book explains the importance of the caravan
trade and its world of exchanges by connecting different types of mobilities
during the transition period, while also demonstrating the resilience of the
network in the face of attempted imperial dominance. The author argues that
the Durrani Afghan empire emerged as a new center of power and exchange
with growing surplus of trade and patronage networks that connected mer-
cenaries, merchants, and bankers in post-Mughal South Asia. The Durrani
Empire not only preserved the network of caravan exchanges between Central
and South Asia, but also benefited from its expansion and the arrival of indigo,
silk, and manufactured cotton cloths. Lally’s conclusion challenges the dom-
inant notion that reduces Central Asia to merely an intermediate space for
east-west trade, and its connections with South Asia to merchant communities
and religious networks. Readers who are aware of the recent enrichment of the
field with James Pickett’s Polymaths of Islam and Walid Ziad’s Hidden Caliphate
will find this book equally satisfying in its contribution to the scholarship of
early modern Eurasia.
The Eurasian overland caravan trade was the backbone of communications,
exchanges and, imperial conquests throughout many centuries. However,
according to the traditional narrative, the emergence of ocean trade connect-
ing the rims of the Asian coastal trade centers interrupted the status quo of the
caravan trade. Building on trends in recent scholarship and presenting work
based on rich archival research, Lally challenges this notion by demonstrating
Downloaded from Brill.com09/03/2023 11:45:01AM
via communal account