INT. J. sci. EDUC., 1993, VOL. 15, NO. 2, 175-197
Agreement between student expectations,
experiences and actual objectives of
practicals in the natural sciences at the
Open university of The Netherlands
Paul Kirschner, Marthie Meester, Evert Middelbeek and Henry Hermans,
Open university of The Netherlands
The research reported on here is concerned with the (mis)conceptions of students with respect to the
objectives which can be achieved by different types of practicals. Students taking part in four different
Natural Science practicals were questioned prior to the practical as to the objectives they anticipated
encountering. Three of the practicals were traditional laboratory practicals, one was an interactive
videodisc practical. These same students were questioned subsequent to the completion of the practicals
as to the objectives they felt they encountered. The expectations and experiences of the students were
compared with the objectives that experts said were actually present in the practicals.
The most important conclusion which can be drawn from this research is that expectations of students
with respect to the objectives of what they are about to study unequivocally influence what they encounter,
independent of what actually is present. Specifically the findings are: what is anticipated significantly
influences what is encountered; not anticipating an objective leads to not encountering that objective, even
when the objective is present in the material; anticipating an objective leads to encountering that objective
even when it is not present; there are a number of objectives which can be considered 'basic' practical
objectives which are present in all practicals studied regardless of type; there are objectives which appear
to be unique to the different types of practicals. These results have far-reaching ramifications for both
educational research and educational design.
Introduction
The Open university of The Netherlands (OuN), an institution for open higher
distance education, offers courses and degree programmes in seven subject areas, one
of which is the Natural Sciences. The open quality of the OuN is characterized by
open admission, open programming, and open study pace of study. Open admission
means that there are no formal entry requirements for students. Admission does not
depend on having received a diploma from one of the accepted preparatory
secondary or tertiary institutes.* This does not mean that there is no prerequisite
knowledge required for the successful completion of a course nor that the level of the
courses is lower than that of other institutions for higher education, but rather that
having attained the necessary prior knowledge is not measured by previously
received diplomas. The only restriction is that a student must be at least 18 years old
to attend. Thus the OuN is an institute for adult education. Open programming means
* In order to gain admission to a traditional university in The Netherlands, a student must possess a
diploma from either an academic secondary school (America: high school) or one of the many institutions
of higher vocational education.
0950-0693/93 $10·00 © 1993 Taylor & Francis Ltd.