KCl-induced high temperature corrosion of selected
commercial alloys
Part I: chromia-formers
S. Kiamehr*, K. V. Dahl, M. Montgomery and M. A. J. Somers
Laboratory testing of selected chromia-forming alloys was performed to rank the
materials and gain further knowledge on the mechanism of KCl-induced high
temperature corrosion. The investigated alloys were stainless steels EN1.4021,
EN1.4057, EN1.4521, TP347H (coarse-grained), TP347HFG (fine-grained),
Sanicro 28 and the nickel-based alloys 625, 263 and C276. Exposure was
performed at 600 8C for 168 h in flowing N
2
(g)þ5%O
2
(g)þ15% H
2
O(g) (vol.%).
Samples were covered with KCl powder prior to exposure. A salt-free exposure
was also performed for comparison. Corrosion morphology and products were
studied with scanning electron microscopy (SEM), energy dispersive X-ray
spectroscopy (EDS) and X-ray diffractometry (XRD). It was observed that in the
salt-free exposure, stainless steels TP347H (coarse-grained) and EN1.4521 failed
to form a thin protective oxide layer compared to the oxide formed on the other
alloys. In the presence of solid KCl, all the alloys showed significant corrosion.
Measurement of corrosion extent indicated that alloys EN1.4057, Sanicro 28 and
625 show a better performance compared to the industrial state of the art
material TP347HFG under laboratory conditions. An additional test was
performed with KCl vapor in static air for the same duration and at the same
temperature.This was undertaken to investigate the role of the vapor phase and
revealed that KCl vapor at 600 8C can initiate attack.
1 Introduction
During the past decades, increasing concern about the global
warming effects has been a large driving force for utilization of
CO
2
-neutral fuels. Combustion of biomass instead of fossil fuels
is an attractive option, especially in countries with large forest
and agricultural resources. However, employing biomass is not
free from challenges. Compared to the fossil fuels, such as coal
and oil, biomass contains large amounts of alkali and chlorine.
Consequently combustion of biomass leads to deposits rich in
alkali chlorides, especially potassium chloride KCl, on the heat
exchangers. Such deposits are so corrosive that obtaining
sufficient life time of components in biomass fired power plants
necessitates a reduction of the outlet steam temperature to a
value below that for fossil fuel fired power plants. Currently, the
maximum outlet steam temperature for biomass firing is 540 8C
for state of the art power plants using stainless steels such as
TP347HFG as superheater tube material [1]. The relatively low
steam temperature makes the biomass based power plants less
efficient compared to plants firing fossil fuels. Therefore
reducing the extent of KCl-induced corrosion will directly affect
the feasibility of substituting fossil fuels with biomass.
High temperature alloys often rely on the formation of a
chromium-rich oxide layer for protection against corrosion.
Therefore any interaction with the environment that damages
this oxide layer accelerates corrosion of the underlying alloy. It
has been shown [2] that in alkali-containing environments, a
reaction between the alkali elements and chromia in the oxide
layer can lead to the formation of alkali chromate. The reaction
for the case of potassium chloride is:
4KClðs; gÞþ Cr
2
O
3
þð5=2ÞO
2
ðgÞ¼ 2K
2
CrO
4
þ 2Cl
2
ðgÞ
ð1Þ
Chromate formation depletes the original oxide of chromium
and hence the oxide is no longer protective [2,3]. Consequently it
is anticipated that with an increase in the alloy’s chromium
content, the overall damage could be mitigated as a protective
S. Kiamehr, K. V. Dahl, M. Montgomery, M. A. J. Somers
Technical University of Denmark (DTU), Department of Mechanical
Engineering, Produktionstorvet, Building 425, 2800 Kgs., Lyngby,
(Denmark)
E-mail: sabag@mek.dtu.dk
M. Montgomery
COWI A/S Parallelvej 2, 2800 Kgs., Lyngby, (Denmark)
1414 DOI: 10.1002/maco.201408213 Materials and Corrosion 2015, 66, No. 12
www.matcorr.com wileyonlinelibrary.com © 2015 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim