Valorization of Sugar Beet Pulp via Torrefaction with a Focus on the
Effect of the Preliminary Extraction of Pectins
Paola Brachi,*
,§
Evelina Riianova,
⊥
Michele Miccio,
†
Francesco Miccio,
‡
Giovanna Ruoppolo,
§
and Riccardo Chirone
§
§
Institute for Research on Combustion, National Research Council, P.le Tecchio 80, 80125 Napoli, Italy
⊥
Department of Production Safety and Industrial Ecology, Ufa State Aviation Technical University, K. Marks 12, 450077 Ufa, Russian
Federation
†
Department of Industrial Engineering, University of Salerno, via Giovanni Paolo II 132, 84084 Fisciano (SA), Italy
‡
Institute of Science and Technology for Ceramics (ISTEC-CNR), via Granarolo 64, 48018 Faenza (RA), Italy
ABSTRACT: An agro-industrial residue, i.e., sugar beet pulp, was taken into consideration in this work as a feedstock for
valorization as a solid fuel and, potentially, as a source of valuable biochemicals obtainable from the torgas condensable fraction.
To this end, an experimental program based on torrefaction of such a residue after pectin extraction (PE-SBP) was performed.
The alternative scenario of raw sugar beet pulp (raw-SBP) torrefaction was also investigated for comparison. Raw biomasses and
torrefaction products were analyzed by different techniques including thermogravimetric analysis and derivative
thermogravimetry (TGA-DTG), Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy (FTIR), gas chromatrography coupled to mass
spectrometry (GC/MS), and proximate and ultimate analyses. This allowed the comparative investigation of the role played by
the pectin extraction method and the torrefaction temperature on the process performance and main properties of the resulting
solid products. Outcomes showed that light torrefaction (200-240 °C) is a suitable and more energy-efficient process for
production of high quality solid fuels from SBP. Moreover, it resulted that PE-SBP is better than raw-SBP as a feedstock due to
its lower nitrogen and ash content.
1. INTRODUCTION
Sugar beet is the second largest source of sugar across the
world, after sugar cane. In 2009, approximately 20% of the
world’s sugar production (153.4 million tons) was obtained
from sugar beet.
1
Sugar beet pulp (SBP) is the main solid
byproduct of the sugar beet industry. On a dry mass basis,
about 130 kg of sugar and 50 kg of dried SBP can be obtained
from 1 t.
2
Due to its high organic matter content
(carbohydrates, protein, fat, oil, etc.), SBP represents a cheap
(around 110 €/t dry matter) and abundant (e.g., the
production in Europe is around 14 million t/y dry matter)
source of valuable biomass and nutrients.
3
In detail, its
carbohydrate (cellulose, hemicellulose, pectin, and others)
content has been reported to be as high as 75-85% (w/w, dry
basis) and its lignin content as low as 1-4% (w/w, dry basis).
SBP contains approximately 25% wt pectin, 24% wt cellulose,
and 36% wt hemicellulose.
4
At present SBP is mostly sold as animal feed at a relatively
low price due to its relatively low protein content compared to
the requirements of most ruminants, which entail the use of an
extra protein source.
5
However, alternative uses of such
valuable byproducts of the sugar industry are currently being
investigated to enhance its valorization. These mostly include
the use of SBP as a carbohydrate source for the production of
(i) food fibers
5
to be incorporated into bread, cookies,
spaghetti, and meat products and (ii) biofuels, especially liquid
fuels such as bio-oil
6
and bioethanol.
7
Chen et al.
8
also
investigated the use of SBP as a filler in poly(lactic acid)
composites, whereas Pavier and Gandini
9
evaluated the possible
use of SBP as a source of polyol for the production of urethanes
and polyurethanes.
Due to its high content of pectic polysaccharides, SBP could
also be a potential source of pectins, which are substances
currently used in industry mainly for their gelling and
thickening properties. Pectins from SBP have poor gelling
properties compared with commercial pectins from apple
pomace or citrus peels under classical conditions. However,
SBP pectins have already proved to have great potential for
alternative applications that justify its extraction. In particular,
these include the use of SBP pectins as (a) cloud stabilizers in
drinks;
3
(b) water-absorbing agents in sanitary products;
3
and
(c) substrates for the biosorption of copper, cadmium, and
lead.
10
On the other side, pectin extraction from SBP leaves a
solid residue, which has currently no known use and poses a
disposal issue.
In this context, the potential valorization of pectin-extracted
sugar beet pulp (PE-SBP) as a solid fuel was taken into
consideration in this work. The major challenge in using such a
residue (PE-SBP) as an energy source lies in the operational
and logistic limitations associated with its inherent chemical
and physical properties. Pectin-free beet pulp, being of
biological origin, has high oxygen content, low calorific value,
low bulk density, high moisture content, pronounced
hygroscopic behavior, and a strong tendency to biodegrade
Received: June 21, 2017
Revised: August 5, 2017
Article
pubs.acs.org/EF
© XXXX American Chemical Society A DOI: 10.1021/acs.energyfuels.7b01766
Energy Fuels XXXX, XXX, XXX-XXX