Copyright © by the Association of American Medical Colleges. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Academic Medicine, Vol. 94, No. 1 / January 2019 115
Research Report
Abstract
Purpose
Although the field of medical education
research is growing and residents are
increasingly recruited to participate
as subjects in research studies, little is
known about their experiences. The
goal of this study was to explore the
experiences and perceptions of residents
who are study participants in medical
education research.
Method
A phenomenographic approach
was chosen to examine the range
of residents’ experiences as research
participants. A maximum variation
sampling strategy was used to identify
residents with diverse experiences.
Semistructured interviews that explored
experiences as research participants
were conducted with 19 residents in
internal medicine, general surgery, and
pediatrics at the University of Toronto in
2015–2016.
Results
The perceptions and experiences of
participants fell into two categories.
First, participation was seen as a
professional responsibility to advance
the profession, including a desire to
improve future educational practices and
a sense of responsibility to contribute
to the academic cause. Second, the
experience was noted for its personal
impact, including benefits (e.g., receiving
monetary incentives or novel educational
experiences) and risks (e.g., coercion
and breaches of confidentiality). The
time required to participate in a study
was identified as one of the most
important factors affecting willingness
to participate and the impact of
participation.
Conclusions
Being a participant in medical education
research can be perceived in different
ways. Understanding the view of resident
participants is important to optimize
potential benefits and minimize risks and
negative consequences for them, thus
fostering ready participation and high-
quality research.
The field of medical education
research has grown significantly over
the past half century as accreditation
bodies and the public have required
assurance that future doctors receive
high-quality education.
1,2
Consequently,
there has been an increase in demand
for medical education research
3
and for
faculty members who have an academic
focus in this field,
4
along with enhanced
recognition of medical education
research as a valuable endeavor by
academic institutions.
5,6
Reflective of
these trends, there has been a dramatic
increase in the number of health
professions education masters and
doctoral programs worldwide.
7,8
The growth of medical education
research has exceeded the rate of growth
in the number of medical trainees.
9
Because medical education research relies
heavily on medical students and residents
as potential participants for studies, these
individuals are being recruited more
frequently to be the subjects of various
research projects. Although trainees will
benefit from this research in the long run,
the impact on trainees of participating in,
or merely being approached to participate
in, numerous studies must be carefully
considered, as this participation may have
both positive and negative ramifications.
Studies that involve measures of
knowledge or performance may provide
trainees with access to novel educational
experiences, may affect their self-
perceptions, or may cause them to feel
that the researcher’s perception of them
has changed.
10
Because of demanding
clinical schedules, burnout and wellness
are recognized as increasingly important
issues for trainees themselves and for the
quality of health care they provide.
11
The
potential for participation in research
studies that take away time from clinical,
educational, and recreational pursuits
is an important consideration. At the
same time, evidence gathered through
empirical research is needed to improve
medical education practice, which
ultimately benefits trainees’ education.
12
Limited research has been conducted
examining trainees’ experiences as
participants in medical education
research, to our knowledge, and most
studies have involved medical students
rather than residents.
10,13,14
One survey
of 524 medical students reported that
93% felt that medical education research
should be conducted to improve medical
training and 89% were not concerned
about confidentiality when participating
anonymously, but 57% were concerned
about confidentiality when their
participation was not anonymous.
13
Despite the obvious importance and
potential ethical implications of trainee
participation in medical education
research, little is known about the
experiences and perceptions of residents
who are participants in medical education
studies.
15
The experiences of residents
are likely distinct from those of medical
students because residents are busier,
Please see the end of this article for information
about the authors.
Professional Responsibilities and Personal
Impacts: Residents’ Experiences as
Participants in Education Research
Luke A. Devine, MD, MHPE, Shiphra Ginsburg, MD, PhD, Terese Stenfors, PhD,
Tulin D. Cil, MD, MEd, Heather McDonald-Blumer, MD, MScCH,
Catharine M. Walsh, MD, MEd, PhD, and Lynfa Stroud, MD, MEd
Correspondence should be addressed to Luke
A. Devine, University of Toronto, 600 University
Ave., Suite 436, Toronto, ON, Canada, M5G 1X5;
telephone: (416) 586-4800, ext. 2471; e-mail: luke.
devine@sinaihealthsystem.ca.
Copyright © 2018 by the Association of American
Medical Colleges
Acad Med. 2019;94:115–121.
First published online August 14, 2018
doi: 10.1097/ACM.0000000000002411