Advances in Health Sciences Education 6: 121–140, 2001.
© 2001 Kluwer Academic Publishers. Printed in the Netherlands.
121
Students’ Perceptions of Assessment Practices in a
Traditional Medical Curriculum
SARI LINDBLOM-YLÄNNE
*
and KIRSTI LONKA
Development of Studies, P.O. Box 3, 00014 University of Helsinki, Finland (
*
Corresponding
author: E-mail: sari.lindblom-ylanne@helsinki.fi)
Abstract. This study examines advanced medical students’ perceptions of assessment practices and
their ways of studying for examinations as related to their approaches to learning. This study further
validates a cluster model obtained in a previous study through medical students’ interviews. In this
cluster model students were divided into four groups on the basis of their approaches to learning. The
subjects (N = 35) were advanced medical students who volunteered to be interviewed. The interviews
focused on learning strategies, study behaviour and perceptions of the learning environment. The
results indicated that there were no differences in students’ perceptions of the examination proce-
dures. Students in all four groups criticised quite similarly the examination practices. However, the
results showed that students in the four groups reported different ways of preparing for examinations
and, furthermore, had different views of the most functional ways to study for them. This study
brought into light problems that arise in a traditional medical curriculum, particularly concerning
traditional assessment practices.
Key words: assessment, examinations, learning environment, medical education, study approach
Introduction
Assessment methods play a major role in education because they strongly guide
student learning and are thus sometimes referred to as the ‘hidden curriculum’
(Godfrey, 1995; Van der Vleuten, 1996). Teaching and assessment should be in
‘constructive alignment’, as Biggs (1996) succinctly notes. This means that the
basic principle of the learner’s active role in creating meaning should also guide the
learning objectives and criteria forming the basis on which student performance is
assessed. Thus, traditional ways of assessing learning, such as measuring factual
recall, are not satisfactory when problem-solving or application of knowledge is
being measured. Assessment criteria should support teachers’ teaching strategies
and students’ learning strategies (Brown et al., 1997). Consequently, the criteria
should be derived from the learning context.
Assessment in higher education has two competing goals: developmental and
judgmental (Brown et al., 1997). The purpose of the former is to improve student
learning, whereas the latter is concerned with consistency, uniformity and fairness
in licencing the student to proceed to the next stage. Often judgmental assessment