Journal of Autoimmunity (2002) 19, 233–240 doi:10.1006/jaut.2002.0620, available online at http://www.idealibrary.com on
Restriction in the Usage of Variable Regions in T-cells
Infiltrating Valvular Tissue from Rheumatic Heart Disease
Patients
F. Figueroa
1
, M. Gonza ´lez
1
, F. Carrio ´n
1
, C. Lobos
1
, F. Turner
2
, N. Lasagna
1
and
F. Valde ´s
1
1
Laboratory of Immunology, Faculty of
Medicine, Universidad de los Andes and
2
Department of Cardiology, Hospital del
To ´ rax and Hospital Dipreca, Santiago,
Chile
Received 8 February 2002
Accepted 10 September 2002
Key words: rheumatic fever,
rheumatic heart disease, T cells,
TCR V region, superantigen
Rheumatic Heart Disease (RHD) is a delayed consequence of a pharyngeal
infection with group A streptococcus (GAS), usually ascribed to a cross-
reactive immune response to the host’s cardiac tissues. Several GAS proteins
have been reported to be superantigens, also raising the possibility that T cells
in RHD could be driven by superantigens. We therefore analysed the variable
beta (V) repertoire of T cells infiltrating heart valves from chronic RHD
patients undergoing elective valvular surgery. We analysed 15 valve speci-
mens from patients with longstanding quiescent RHD and control valves from
four non-rheumatic individuals. Total RNA was extracted from fresh valve
tissue and employed to amplify 22 V genes by RT-PCR. In valvular tissue, a
restricted number of only 2 to 9 V regions were detected as opposed to the
findings in control valves. In 8 RHD valves, the expression of V1, 2, 3, 5.1, 7,
8, 9 or 14 was marked. These V regions have been related to GAS super-
antigens. Our results evidence the presence of a restricted set of T lymphocytes
in valvular tissue from a majority of patients with chronic RHD and suggest
that valvular sequelae in these patients might be related to a local antigen or
superantigen driven inflammatory process that persists even many years after
the initial triggering event. © 2002 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved.
Introduction
Acute Rheumatic Fever (ARF) and Rheumatic Heart
Disease (RHD) continue to be the main cause of
acquired heart disease among children and young
adults in the world [1], accounting for the majority of
cardiac operations in developing countries [2]. ARF is
the consequence of a pharyngeal infection with Group
A streptococcus (GAS) in a susceptible host, leading to
an immune-mediated systemic disease with multi-
organ involvement [3]. While most disease manifesta-
tions are transient and leave no residua, rheumatic
carditis, the most severe complication of ARF, can lead
to valvular scarring with permanent sequelae in 35 to
79% of cases [4].
Current evidence suggests that the pathogenesis of
heart damage in ARF is related to the occurrence of
extensive immunological cross-reactivity between
streptococcal components and host antigens such as
cardiac myosin and valvular glycoproteins [5, 6]. This
so-called molecular mimicry would therefore be
responsible for the cross-reactive humoral and cellular
immune response that is characteristic of ARF patients
[7, 8]. This would also explain the inflammatory
lesions that are typically found in both cardiac and
valvular tissues [9]. Lymphocytic infiltrates have been
identified in valvular tissue from patients with acute
rheumatic carditis [10, 11] and also in valves removed
10–20 years after the initial attack of ARF [12]. In both
cases, the cellular infiltrates are composed primarily
of T cells [10, 12]. In addition, T-cell lines from affected
heart valves have been shown to recognize rheuma-
togenic strains of GAS [13] and also to cross-react
with antigens derived from heart valve tissues and
streptococcal M protein [14].
More recently, it has been shown that several strep-
tococcal components, possibly including M protein
[15], are superantigens [16–19]. These molecules inter-
act with specific elements within the variable beta
(V) region of the T-cell receptor (TCR), stimulating 5
to 20% of resting T cells, regardless of their antigenic
specificity [20]. This mode of activation can cause
expansion of potentially autoreactive T cells capable
of triggering [21] or expanding a pathogenic auto-
immune response in patients with ARF [22]. Only one
group has published information concerning the
usage of V genes in cardiac lesions from rheumatic
Correspondence to: Fernando Figueroa M.D., Faculty of Medicine,
Universidad de los Andes, Av San Carlos de Apoquindo 2200,
6782468 Las Condes, Santiago, Chile. Tel.: 56-2-214 1258; Fax:
56-2-214 1752; E-mail: ffiguero@uandes.cl
233
0896–8411/02/$-see front matter © 2002 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved.