Delivered by Ingenta to: Guest User
IP: 193.191.134.1 On: Thu, 02 Jun 2016 12:27:52
Copyright: Aerospace Medical Association
RESEARCH ARTICLE
1044 Aviation, Space, and Environmental Medicine x Vol. 80, No. 12 x December 2009
G ERMONPRE P, PONTIER J-M, GEMPP E, BLATTEAU J-E, DENEWETH S,
LAFÉRE P, MARRONI A, BALESTRA C. Pre-dive vibration effect on bubble
formation after a 30-m dive requiring a decompression stop. Aviat
Space Environ Med 2010; 81:1044–8.
Introduction: The preconditioning of divers to reduce post-dive de-
compression sickness (DCS) has gained increased interest in diving med-
ical research over the last few years. The beneficial effects of physical
exercise, oxygen breathing, hyperbaric exposure, heat exposure, hyper-
hydration, or nitroglycerin administration before the dive are only a few
examples of ongoing research. In this work, we investigated the effects
of pre-dive whole-body vibration on post-dive bubble formation. Meth-
ods: Following French Navy standard dive procedures, 14 healthy male
military divers performed 2 identical dives 1 wk apart to 30 m of seawa-
ter (msw) for 30 min. One of the dives was randomly preceded by a
30-min whole-body vibration session (frequencies 35-40 Hz) 1 h before
the dive. Post-dive bubbles were measured precordially 30, 60, and 90
min after the dive and were graded according to the Kissman Integrated
Severity Score (KISS) protocol, with and without knee flexing. Arterial
endothelial function was measured before and after vibration using flow
mediated dilation (FMD) measurement. Results: A significant reduction
in bubble scores was observed after the “vibration” dive. Conclusion: As
there was no observed change in FMD after vibration, we do not believe
a nitric oxide mediated mechanism is involved; rather, a mechanical
dislodgement or enhanced lymphatic elimination of gas nuclei is
hypothesized.
Keywords: scuba diving, decompression sickness prevention, bubble
formation, whole-body vibration.
T
HE PREVENTION OF decompression sickness
(DCS) in scuba diving is a matter of ongoing re-
search. Although currently available decompression
tables and algorithms are capable of reducing the risk
of DCS, they cannot eliminate it completely (16). A
substantial proportion of DCS cases are classified “un-
explained” when the diver has complied with the proce-
dures imposed by the chosen decompression model
(dive computer or dive table). Because of this, a large
body of research is currently directed at reducing the in-
cidence of (micro) gas bubbles during decompression.
However, research into the optimization of decompres-
sion procedures is hampered by the large inter- (and
even intra-) individual variability of post-dive decom-
pression bubble formation (4).
Another approach to reducing bubble formation after
a dive is to “pre-condition” the diver prior to immer-
sion. The general idea behind this approach is that
post-dive decompression bubbles originate from the en-
dothelial surface. Reports have been published on the
From the Centre for Hyperbaric Oxygen Therapy, Military Hospital,
Brussels, Belgium.
This manuscript was received for review in June 2009. It was
accepted for publication in September 2009.
Address reprint requests to: Dr. Peter Germonpré, M.D., Centre for
Hyperbaric Oxygen Therapy, Military Hospital Brussels, Rue Bruyn,
1 B-1120 Brussels, Belgium; peter.germonpre@mil.be.
Reprint & Copyright © by the Aerospace Medical Association,
Alexandria, VA.
DOI: 10.3357/ASEM.2588.2010
Pre-Dive Vibration Effect on Bubble Formation After
a 30-m Dive Requiring a Decompression Stop
Peter Germonpré, Jean-Michel Pontier,
Emmanuel Gempp, Jean-Eric Blatteau,
Stefaan Deneweth, Pierre Lafère, Alessandro Marroni,
and Costantino Balestra
beneficial effects of pre-dive exercise (5,14), oxygen
breathing (9), pre-dive hyperbaric sessions (19,24), heat
preconditioning (6), hydration (15), and nitric oxide
(NO) donor administration (13). Most of these experi-
ments try to influence bubble formation by modifying
biophysical or chemical properties of the endothelial
surface, on which gas bubbles or nuclei are presumed to
be forming. In this paper, we report the possibility of
reducing post-dive bubble formation by a short bout of
mechanical low-frequency vibrations of the whole body
1 h before the dive.
METHODS
The study protocol was approved by the Academic
Ethical Committee of the Brussels Free University and
by the French Navy Experimental Ethical Committee.
After consent, 14 healthy male military divers (age
range: 23-44, mean 29 yr, height: 177 6 6 cm, weight:
79.44 6 10.7 kg) participated in this prospective study.
All divers were in good health, did not take any medica-
tion, and had never suffered from DCS. They performed
two identical dives 1 wk apart. Each dive was made in
open (sea) water, to a depth of 30 m, for 30 min on the
bottom with a calibrated effort during the dive (fin
swimming at a determined leg frequency and speed).
A 9-min decompression stop was made at a depth of
3 msw according to the French Navy standard diving
procedures (MN90 diving tables). All subjects abstained
from diving, smoking, or physical exercise for 48 h be-
fore each dive.
In a randomized fashion, one of the dives was pre-
ceded by a whole-body vibration session of 30 min du-
ration using a commercially available vibration mattress