International Journal of Applied Engineering Research ISSN 0973-4562 Volume 13, Number 6 (2018) pp. 3939-3947
© Research India Publications. http://www.ripublication.com
3939
The Effect of ISO 9001 to Oman Higher Education Operational
Performance: Buraimi University College as a Case Study
Dr. Adalia Martin* and Dr. Fawaz Ali Thawabieh
#
*Oman College of Management & Technology, Muscat, Oman.
#
Modern College of Business and Science, Muscat, Oman.
Abstract
This paper examines the relationship between the ISO 9001
Total Quality Management (TQM) factors, that are presented
in the Baldrige Education Criteria for Performance Excellence
framework (leadership, strategic planning, stakeholder and
market focus, measurement and analysis, staff focus and
process management), and the seventh element which is the
operational performance results. The study, which was
conducted at the Buraimi University College of Oman, showed
that TQM is applicable to higher education according to the
perception of the staff members. The study also showed that
leadership, stakeholder and market focus and staff focus have a
significant positive influence on operational performance of
higher education. The results agreed with the literature findings
that the success of TQM appears to be determined by intangible
or soft practices rather than tangible or hard practices.
Keywords: TQM, Performance Measures, Higher Education,
Operational Performance, Baldrige Education Criteria
INTRODUCTION
The Buraimi University College (BUC) is the first university
college in Al-Buraimi governorate, northwest of the Sultanate
of Oman, on the border of United Arab Emirates. The
institution has started its academic programmes in Academic
Year 2003- 2004. Currently, the institution has a total of 100
academic and administrative employees. Within the Sultanate,
BUC among with Gulf College, German University of
Technology, and Shinas College adopts the ISO 9001:2008
standards as their external accrediting body for their
programmes. Having its first institutional audit using ISO
standards in 2012. Locally, the Oman Authority for Academic
Accreditation (OAAA) is the national authority imposed the
institutional accreditation standards. BUC has started adopting
the ISO standards on 2015 in partnership with California State
University.
Among the most rigorous empirical studies that examine how
implementation of the ISO 9001 quality management standard
affects employers‟ outcomes and practices, mostly were
conducted by U.S. manufacturers. Terlaak and King (2006)
found that plants which adopt ISO 9001 typically increase their
rate of production growth. Others studies on ISO 9001
certification were to be associated with subsequent abnormal
returns along a host of financial metrics including stock prices
(Corbett et al. 2005; Sharma, 2005). Various studies found
benefits strongest among small firms (Docking and Dowen
1999; McGuire and Dilts 2008) and among those with a modest
level of technological diversity, and/or early adopters (Benner
and Veloso 2008). King and Lenox (2001) found that adopting
ISO 9001 leads plants to reduce waste generation and toxic
chemical emissions suggests that implementing the quality
management standard has positive spillover effects that can
improve environmental management practices. Interestingly,
few researches examined how the ISO 9001 quality standard
affects product or process quality or employees.
The increasing pressure of globalization and the dynamism of
the sector have resulted in the quality frenzy in the higher
education sector since the last decade. Greater mobility of
students and staff in paired with increasing demands on
comparability and transparency on academic programmes
(Holma & Pakalna, 2007) have led to the popular adoption and
implementation of QMS such as the ISO 9001 that were
originally designed for the industry sector (Pratasavitskaya &
Sternsaker, 2010) by many higher education institutions (HEIs)
with aims of improving their customer services and securing a
competitive edge in the sector.
Total quality management (TQM) is an established field of
study where academics, consultants, engineers and quality
practitioners have contributed their ideas towards its
advancement. This group has given many definitions to TQM.
TQM is formally defined as both a philosophy and set of
guiding principles that represent the foundation of continuous
improving organizations (Besterfield et al., 2003). It is the
process of changing the fundamental culture of an organization
and redirecting it toward superior product or service quality. It
is the philosophy that stresses the principles of customer
satisfaction, employee involvement and continuous process
improvement for achieving high levels of process performance
and quality (Krajewski et al., 2007). TQM can be considered as
a different approach to management, pioneered by Crosby,
Deming, Ichikawa, Juran and others (Brah et al., 2000).
In response to government initiatives at standardizing and
improving the quality of high education, there has been a trend
of uniformity in the choice of QMS being implemented in the
HEIs, namely the ISO 9001:2008 (Harvey, 2002). The ISO
9001:2008-based QMS is a process orientated system
(Michalska-Ćwiek, 2009) that helps to ensure properly written
and documented procedures are created and implemented by
the organization. These procedures cover all functions of the
operations which include the organization structure,
responsibilities, procedures, documentation, division
competency, processes and resources of the organization
(Michalska-Ćwiek, 2009). Studies have been done throughout
the years on the adoption and the implementation of the QMS
in HEIs and have yielded both positive and negative reviews