JPII 11(4) (2022) 511-518
Jurnal Pendidikan IPA Indonesia
http://journal.unnes.ac.id/index.php/jpii
ENHANCEMENT OF INDONESIAN HIGH SCHOOL STUDENT
CONCEPTUAL MASTERY ON VSEPR TOPIC
USING VIRTUAL SIMULATION OF MOLECULE SHAPES:
A CASE STUDY OF QUASI-EXPERIMENTAL EVIDENCE
E. Stiawan*
1
, R. Basuki
2
, L. Liliasari
3
, I. Rohman
4
1,2
Military Chemistry Department, Faculty of Military Mathematics and Natural Sciences,
Republic of Indonesia Defense University, Indonesia
3,4
Chemistry Education Department, Faculty of Mathematics and Natural Sciences Education,
Universitas Pendidikan Indonesia, Indonesia
DOI: 10.15294/jpii.v11i4.36385
Accepted: April 30
th
2022. Approved: December 29
th
2022. Published: December 30
th
2022
ABSTRACT
The Valence Shell Electron Pair Repulsion (VSEPR) is an essential topic for high school student’s fundamental
understanding of 3D shapes of chemical compounds. Due to the spatial aspect of the topic, the students were
forced to imagine the geometry of the molecule by predicting the free or bonded electron pair repulsion. Suitable
learning media to accommodate those features should be precisely selected to help students properly understand
the geometry of the molecule based on the VSEPR topic. This study compared the significant difference in the
application of two media of animation video and interactive simulation toward the control and experimental
groups, respectively, to enhance conceptual mastery of the VSEPR topic. This study was a statistical quasi-exper-
iment study with two classes of control (animation video) and experimental (interactive simulation) groups. The
results of the significant difference test of the groups showed that the distribution of the experimental and control
groups was not normal (significantly different) and normal (not significantly different), respectively. Analysis
results using Mann-Whitney for the non-parametric free two samples comparative test with a 95% confidence
level showed that the application of virtual simulation on the experimental group impacted more in improving
the conceptual mastery of the VSEPR topic. Furthermore, there was an identified significant improvement in
sub-concepts of the VSEPR topic in binding pair, molecular shape, and electron repulsion. These findings could
support the teachers in designing lesson plans for students to master the VSEPR topic.
© 2022 Science Education Study Program FMIPA UNNES Semarang
Keywords: conceptual mastery; learning media; virtual simulation; VSEPR topic
*Correspondence Address
E-mail: elvastiawan@gmail.com
INTRODUCTION
The VSEPR topic, as one of the chemistry
topics at the high school level, emphasizes basic
understanding of molecular geometry of simple
covalent compounds. This concept is considered
fundamental for a further chemistry topic, especi-
ally in organic chemistry and biochemistry. Many
studies have reported that some students found
difficulties in imagining three-dimensional struc-
tural molecule shapes (Rahmawati et al., 2021).
The topic regarding the geometry of molecules
categorized as abstract is the main reason for stu-
dents’ difficulties in properly visualizing molecu-
le shapes (Kiernan et al., 2021).
Instead of using the widely used physical
VSEPR model, sometimes called a moly mod kit,
some digital learning media can also help stu-
dents visualize the geometry of molecule shapes,
for example, animation video, and virtual simula-
tion. As multimedia-based learning and molecule
visualizations have transformed over the past de-