PREDICTING THE DISSOLUTION OF FOUR ROCK PHOSPHATES
IN FLOODED ACID SULFATE SOILS OF THAILAND
S. Yampracha, T. Attanandana, A. Sidibe ´ -Diarra, A. Srivihok, and R. S. Yost
The dissolution of rock phosphate (RP) in soils, a reaction funda-
mental to the effectiveness of direct application of RP, depends on both
the RP and soil properties. Four RP materials of varying solubility,
namely, Gafsa RP, Tilemsi RP, Taiba RP, and a local RP, Kanchanaburi
RP, were incubated with six flooded acid sulfate soils to quantify factors
affecting the dissolution of RP. The differences between dilute NaOH-P
extracted from soils treated with and without RP materials (%NaOH-P)
were used to estimate the dissolution of RP materials. A nonlinear
Mitscherlich equation was used to describe the changes in %NaOH-P
over incubation time. The coefficients of the fitted Mitscherlich equation
were then regressed on soil and RP properties to develop an RP model.
Soil acidity measured by pH and KCl-extractable aluminum (Al) were
the soil properties that most affected RP dissolution and thus were
included in the RP model. RP solubility as assessed using the second
extraction with 2% citric acid as a percentage of rock and the particle
size of RP (G 100 mesh) were the RP properties found most important
in predicting dissolution and were include in the model. The calcium
carbonate content of the RP affected the changes of pH in six acid sulfate
soils after mixing with RP materials. (Soil Science 2006;171:200–209)
Key words: Acid sulfate soils, flooded, rock phosphate, dissolution.
P
HOSPHORUS (P) deficiency in flooded acid
sulfate soils of Thailand is one of the limiting
factors causing decreases in rice growth and yield
(Attanandana and Vacharotayan, 1984). In order
for rock phosphate (RP) to become available
for crops, there are at least two reactions that are
critical: dissolution of RP and sorption of the
dissolved RP. In this paper, we concentrate on
the dissolution of RP. RP has been recommen-
ded for rice cultivation in acid sulfate soils of
Thailand (Department of Agriculture).
1
The ex-
treme acidity of acid sulfate soils, in which soil
pH can be less than 3 to 4, is a logical choice
because acidity is key to the dissolution of RP.
In addition to soil and RP characteristics, dis-
solution of RP depends on many factors such
as crop species, crop management, and climate
conditions (Sidibe ´-Diarra et al., 2004). Soil
characteristics such as acidity, clay content, or-
ganic matter, aluminum (Al), iron (Fe), calcium
(Ca), and P status were reported as limiting
factors to the dissolution of RP (Bolan and
Hedley, 1990; Chu et al., 1962; Hammond
et al., 1986; Kanabo and Gilkes, 1987). High
soil Ca status usually reduces RP dissolution
and is frequently measured as Ca saturation, ex-
changeable Ca, and Ca exchangeable capacity
(Babare et al., 1997; Hammond et al., 1986;
MacKay et al., 1986; Wright et al., 1992). Other
soil properties that control the dissolution of
RP include soil pH and P sorption capacity.
Chu et al. (1962) suggested that the dissolution
of RP decreased with increasing soil pH but that
the Fe-phosphate formed varied both with soil
pH and the low free Fe content of the soil. RP
dissolved more completely in the soils with
low pH and free Fe oxide content. Chien et al.
(1980) found that the dissolution of North
Carolina RP was related to reactive Al, which
200
0038-075X/06/17103-200–209 March 2006
Soil Science Vol. 171, No. 3
Copyright * 2006 by Lippincott Williams & Wilkins, Inc. Printed in U.S.A.
University of Hawaii, Honolulu, HI 96822. Dr. R. S. Yost is corresponding
author. E-mail: rsyost)hawaii.edu
1
Department of Agriculture. 2004. Soil and fertilizer management (in Thai).
Available at www.doa.go.th (verified May 11, 2004).
Received July 27, 2005; accepted Oct. 10, 2005.
DOI: 10.1097/01.ss.0000199699.01828.21
Copyr ight © Lippincott Williams & Wilkins. Unauthor iz ed reproduction of this article is prohibited.