This article has been accepted for inclusion in a future issue of this journal. Content is final as presented, with the exception of pagination.
IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON COMPONENTS, PACKAGING AND MANUFACTURING TECHNOLOGY 1
Determining the Stopband of a Periodic Bed of
Nails From the Dispersion Relation
Measurements Prediction
Shoukry I. Shams, Member, IEEE, and Ahmed A. Kishk, Fellow, IEEE
Abstract—It is useful to determine the stopband of a bed of
nails that can be used for packaging applications. The traditional
methodology to identify the cell characteristics is to use the
eigenmode solver, which is a numerical method that cannot
be validated using a measurement setup. Here, we introduce a
mathematical procedure to extract the dispersion relation out of
the scattering parameters. The scattering parameters express the
transmission and the reflection at the ports, which are functions
of the phase constant of the propagating modes inside the device
under test. A measurement setup is established by placing several
successive cell rows inside a Ku-band rectangular waveguide.
The proposed algorithm is validated through examples of well-
known dispersion relations. The extracted dispersion relation
with the introduced methodology is in good agreement with the
one obtained from the eigenmode solver. The ride gap waveguide
is used as an application example.
Index Terms—Dispersion relation, periodic cells, ridge gap
waveguide (RGW).
I. I NTRODUCTION
R
ECENTLY, the ridge gap waveguide (RGW) has been
evolving as one of the promising technologies to transfer
the electromagnetic signals in high-frequency bands, espe-
cially for millimeter- and submillimeter-wave applications.
This guiding structure is mainly formed from two parallel
plates. The upper plate is a perfect electrical conductor (PEC)
plate, while the lower plate is the ridge, which is used to guide
the signal in the required path. The ridge is surrounded by an
artificial magnetic conductor (AMC) surface. The signal is able
to propagate inside the parallel-plate PEC–PEC in the form of
quasi-TEM mode. On the other hand, the PEC–AMC boundary
conditions outside the ridge are preventing the leakage of the
signal. The idea of this structure is proposed for the first time
in [1]. This idea is initially developed from the concepts of
hard and soft surfaces presented three decades ago [2], [3].
Many advantages are associated with this type of guiding
structure as it carries the signal in the form of quasi-TEM
mode in an air gap. This leads to having minimal disper-
sion and attenuation as there are no dielectric losses inside
Manuscript received December 7, 2016; revised January 27, 2017; accepted
February 12, 2017. Recommended for publication by Associate Editor
A. Orlandi upon evaluation of reviewers’ comments.
The authors are with the Department of Electrical and Computer Engi-
neering, Concordia University, Montreal, QC H4B 1R6, Canada (e-mail:
shoukry.shams@ieee.org).
Color versions of one or more of the figures in this paper are available
online at http://ieeexplore.ieee.org.
Digital Object Identifier 10.1109/TCPMT.2017.2671518
the structure. The configuration also requires no electrical
contacts between its lower and upper parts, which is a major
problem in other structures like the rectangular waveguides.
These advantages are utilized in many applications such as
antennas and antenna arrays [4], [5].
The first step in the design procedure of such a configuration
is the cell analysis and design. The cell analysis is performed
by the eigenmode solver, which is available in many simula-
tion tools. In this simulation technique, the infinite periodic
boundary conditions are assumed, and the final solution is the
valid values for the propagation constant corresponding to dif-
ferent values of frequencies to specify the dispersion relation
for various modes inside the required structure. Although this
methodology is well established, no experimental setup can be
configured to implement these boundary conditions. The RGW
measurement is introduced before in many articles [6], [7],
but no measurement setup is presented to characterize the unit
cell alone. Some work also is introduced to study the effect of
these cells in the packaging of other technologies such as the
microstrip line packaging [8]–[10]. In the literature, the main
concern about the RGW unit cell is always the stopband of the
cell and the possible techniques to widen this band [11], [12],
which is directly related to the usable frequency band for the
whole circuit. Not much attention is given to the cell analysis
accuracy and validation. Theoretical approaches are presented
in the literature to obtain expressions for the dispersion rela-
tions of the bed of nail unit cells (BNUC). Despite neglecting
some boundary conditions in these trials, some of these
expressions’ results are pretty close to the eigenmode solution
results [13], [14], where the fields are solved inside the real
BNUC structure. In other presented papers, equivalent surface
impedance is assumed to have more simple mathematical
manipulations [15].
Some trials are presented in many articles to obtain the
mode dispersion relation for the given fields inside the struc-
ture [16], [17]. This method was presented to utilize the
finite-difference time-domain solution to extract the dispersion
relation of all modes, which can never be experimentally
implemented as it depends on having full knowledge of the
fields inside the device under test (DUT). In practice, this
might be possible if we can probe the field without having
leakage. This would be limited to cases such as a slotted
waveguide or slotted coaxial line. This would be impossible
to achieve with the presence of the periodic structure. There-
fore, we must depend on deembedding the DUT through the
2156-3950 © 2017 IEEE. Personal use is permitted, but republication/redistribution requires IEEE permission.
See http://www.ieee.org/publications_standards/publications/rights/index.html for more information.