Continuous, Fast, and Safe Aerobic Oxidation of 2‑Ethylhexanal:
Pushing the Limits of the Simple Tube Reactor for a Gas/Liquid
Reaction
Laurent Vanoye,
†
Jiadi Wang,
†
Mertxe Pablos,
†
Re ́ gis Philippe,
†
Claude de Bellefon,
†
and Alain Favre-Re ́ guillon*
,†,‡
†
Laboratoire de Ge ́ nie des Proce ́ de ́ s Catalytiques, UMR 5285, CPE Lyon, 43 bld du 11 nov. 1918, 69100 Villeurbanne, France
‡
Conservatoire National des Arts et Me ́ tiers, CASER-SITI, 292 rue Saint Martin, 75003 Paris, France
* S Supporting Information
ABSTRACT: A continuous-flow microreactor is applied
for the selective aerobic neat oxidation of 2-ethylhexanal.
Under 7.5 bar of O
2
and 10 ppm of Mn(II) as catalyst, a
production of up to 130 g/h of 2-ethylhexanoic acid can be
obtained with a PFA tubing of 7 m (Ø 1.65 mm, reactor
volume ca. 15 mL). The synergistic use of alkali metal salts
and Mn(II) as catalyst improve the selectivity up to 94%
under those conditions. We show that the productivity of
this simple tube microreactor is limited by the thermal
management.
■
INTRODUCTION
2-Ethylhexanoic acid 1 is an important chemical intermediate
used in the production of synthetic lubricants, film plasticizers
for polyvinyl butyral, stabilizers for PVC as well as oil additives,
and functional fluids like automotive coolants.
1,2
Moreover,
metal salts of 2-ethylhexanoic acid are used in wood
preservatives, as catalyst for polyurethane synthesis, as metal
soaps in paint dryers, and in various other applications.
3
This
product belongs to the C8 compounds family and is obtained
through the aldol condensation of butyraldehyde 2.
4,5
An
overview of the industrial synthetic pathway to 1 is shown in
Scheme 1.
According to the patent literature, the oxidation of 2-
ethylhexanal 3 to 2-ethylhexanoic acid 1 is typically performed
in a gas sparged stirred tank or gas lift bubble column reactors
with air or enriched air as the gas phase using molecular oxygen
as the terminal oxidant and with the optional presence of a
catalyst.
6-9
However, this oxidation is strongly exothermic
(Δ
r
H = -287 kJ/mol, adiabatic temperature rise of 1065 K for
pure aldehyde) and proceeds via highly reactive free radical
species; thus an efficient temperature control is claimed to be
critical for the selectivity, the productivity, and the safety of the
process.
6-9
This intrinsically fast reaction presents gas-liquid
mass transfer limitation in most industrial reactors.
6-11
As a
matter of fact, even at the lab scale, the productivities published
in recent articles on aerobic oxidation are affected by the gas to
liquid oxygen mass transfer rate.
12,13
In order to reach the
chemical regime and improve the productivity, advanced
microreactors can be used. They are known to provide better
mass and heat transfers than classical vessels.
14-20
Thus,
continuous flow micro- and millimetric reactors were
demonstrated to be a valuable alternative for the safe and
efficient chemical processing
21-24
and among them aerobic
oxidation of aldehydes.
25,26
While this reaction could be
performed without neither catalysts nor radical initiators, the
reaction rate was greatly increased using metal ions as catalysts,
such as Mn(II) and pure oxygen, inside segmented flow
reactors.
27,28
Other advantages of continuous microreactors are the small
inventory of potentially hazardous chemicals and intermediate
species and their large surface to volume ratio which, besides its
interest for mass and heat transfers, could contribute to inhibit
gas-phase free-radical reactions by recombination on the reactor
walls.
21
The selectivity of the oxidation process is known to be highly
dependent on the aldehyde structure.
27-32
While high
selectivity was observed with linear aliphatic aldehyde,
26
selectivity below 80% toward the corresponding carboxylic
acid was obtained for the target reaction, i.e., the oxidation of 2-
ethylhexanal 3.
12,25,27,30
The synergistic use of alkali metals salts
(i.e., sodium 2-ethylhexanoate) or organic carboxylate salt (i.e.,
ionic liquid) and Mn(II) as catalyst can improve the selectivity
up to 98% while maintaining good productivity of the
process.
27,28
Under these conditions, total conversion of the
aldehyde 3 was achieved using flow chemistry, and the
selectivity was kept high.
Herein, a study about further intensification of the aldehyde
oxidation to the corresponding carboxylic acid using a simple
tube continuous-flow reactor that used cheap, disposable PFA
tubing and undergoing a G-L segmented flow (Taylor flow) is
reported. Also, we sought to use this reactor for the visual
monitoring of the flow. An increase of the internal diameter
(i.d.) of PFA tubing (from 1 mm to 1.65 mm) was the only
modification to our lab scale microreactor.
25,27
For higher i.d.,
regular Taylor flow could not be easily obtained within the
range of the flow rates used. The productivity of this simple
experimental setup was pushed to its limits using tools such as
oxygen mass transfer, catalyst loading, and concentration in
order to maximize the acid yield under safe conditions with a
high purity of the product.
Received: November 2, 2015
Communication
pubs.acs.org/OPRD
© XXXX American Chemical Society A DOI: 10.1021/acs.oprd.5b00359
Org. Process Res. Dev. XXXX, XXX, XXX-XXX