RESEARCH ARTICLE
Analysis of the technical efficiency of the forms of
hospital management based on public‐private
collaboration of the Madrid Health Service, as
compared with traditional management
José Luis Franco Miguel
1
|
Carmen Fullana Belda
2
|
Antonio Rúa Vieites
2
1
Clínica Baviera Group Madrid, Madrid, Spain
2
Comillas Pontifical University ICAI‐ICADE,
Madrid, Spain
Correspondence
José Luis Franco Miguel, Clínica Baviera Group
Madrid, Spain.
Email: jfranco_miguel@hotmail.com
JEL Classification: C14; I12; I18
Summary
Fundamentals: The study aims to carry out a comparative
analysis of the technical efficiency of hospital management
based on public‐private collaboration, as compared with tra-
ditional management. Specifically, we compare traditionally
managed public hospitals, public hospitals managed by a
private finance initiative (PFI), public hospitals managed
through a public‐private partnership (PPP), and hospitals
managed through other forms of management, during the
period 2009 to 2014, in the hospitals dependent on the
Madrid Health Service (SERMAS).
Methods: The study covers all publicly owned general
hospitals under SERMAS, consisting of seven PFI hospitals,
three PPP hospitals, 11 traditionally managed public
hospitals (with the category of general hospital), and four
hospitals managed through other forms of hospital manage-
ment. The technical efficiency indices of the hospitals were
calculated using the data envelopment analysis technique.
Subsequently, a sensitivity analysis was performed by
bootstrapping and variation of model variables to verify
their impact on efficiency. Finally, an analysis of the
evolution of efficiency in the analyzed period was carried
out using the Malmquist Index.
Results: In all the analysis models carried out in the ana-
lyzed period, the hospitals managed based on public‐private
Received: 6 September 2018 Accepted: 7 September 2018
DOI: 10.1002/hpm.2678
Int J Health Plann Mgmt. 2018;1–29. © 2018 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. wileyonlinelibrary.com/journal/hpm 1