Electric Power Systems Research 127 (2015) 271–279
Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Electric Power Systems Research
j o ur na l ho mepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/epsr
Unbalance and harmonic distortion assessment in an experimental
distribution network
Aranzazu D. Martin
a
, Reyes S. Herrera
a
, Jesus R. Vazquez
a,*
, Paul Crolla
b
,
Graeme M. Burt
b
a
University of Huelva, Spain
b
University of Strathclyde, Glasgow, Scotland
a r t i c l e i n f o
Article history:
Received 2 September 2014
Received in revised form 18 May 2015
Accepted 7 June 2015
Available online 26 June 2015
Keywords:
Harmonic distortion source
Distribution networks
Non-linear loads
Unbalance
a b s t r a c t
The identification of voltage and current harmonic distortion and voltage unbalance sources is one of the
main problems in electric distribution systems. In order to overcome it, in this paper the use of two novel
indices is proposed. On the one hand, the Load Characterization Index (LCI) is suggested to calculate the
harmonic distortion introduced by the load. This index identifies linear and non-linear loads in the power
systems. On the other hand, the Unbalance Current Ratio (UCR) is suggested to assign the responsibility
for system unbalance to load and source sides. Both indices can be calculated only from the measurement
of the current at the input of the load and the voltage at the Point of Common Connection (PCC). The main
objective of this paper is to test the performance of these two indices on an experimental three-phase
electrical network. In order to do that, several experimental tests have been considered.
© 2015 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
1. Introduction
Nowadays,the assessment of electric power quality is becoming
increasingly important due to the widespread use of non-linear and
time-varying loads. Otherwise, the uneven distribution of single-
phase loads in the low voltage distribution system, among other
causes, makes the voltage unbalance a problem in the power sys-
tem. In this way, the IEEE Standard establishes the procedure to
assess the voltage and current distortion and unbalance in the
electric network PCC, [1,2]. Power monitoring equipment is fre-
quently used to do that, [3–7]. However, the Standard does not
regulate the procedure to assign the responsibility for the net-
work harmonic distortion and/or unbalance to the different agents
in the electric power system. This is a requirement to decrease
these non-conformities, i.e., knowing the cause of the distortion
and/or unbalance, the best location of the compensation systems
is guaranteed and the most suitable procedure to mitigate them is
established [8].
There are many proposals in technical papers to establish the
responsibility of each agent for the harmonic distortion in power
distribution networks [9–19]. One of the most significant methods
is based on the sign of the harmonic active power. It can be used
*
Corresponding author. Tel.: +34 959217579; fax: +34 959217304.
E-mail address: vazquez@uhu.es (J.R. Vazquez).
with measurements in a single-point, [10,11], or with distributed
measurements systems, [12–15]. This method is based on the fact
that the harmonic active power flows from source to load if the
load is linear, whereas it flows in the opposite direction when it
is a distorting load. One of the indices based on this concept is
the Harmonic Global Index, HGI, which will be considered in the
experimental results assessment.
Other methods are those based on the representation of load and
source sides by means of their corresponding Norton circuits, [16].
There is a further technique called the critical impedance method,
[17]. The drawback of these methods is the necessity of knowing the
network and consumer harmonic impedances. Numeric techniques
have also been used to establish each agent responsibility for the
harmonic distortion in the electric network, for example, neural
networks, [18].
Finally, there is another set of methods in the literature based
on the current decomposition, [9,20,21,28]; among them, the Non-
Colinear Index (NCI), [21], and the Non-Linear Index (NLI), [20],
these will be used in the experimental results assessment in this
paper. Another of those methods is the Load Characterization Index
(LCI), [9], proposed by Herrera and Salmerón, which is based on the
decomposition of current at the input of the load into two compo-
nents: a current component which introduces harmonic distortion
into the system and a second current component which does not
introduce harmonic distortion, and whose harmonic distortion is
the same as that of the voltage.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.epsr.2015.06.005
0378-7796/© 2015 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.