Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
The Journal of Academic Librarianship
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/jacalib
Case studies
Rethinking collection development: improving access and increasing
efficiency through demand driven acquisition
Michael A. Arthur
a,
⁎
, Sarah Rose Fitzgerald
b
a
University Libraries, The University of Alabama, Gorgas 400G, Box 870266, Tuscaloosa, AL 35487, United States of America
b
The University of Alabama, 309D Amelia Gayle Gorgas Library, Box 870266, Tuscaloosa, AL 35487, United States of America
Demand Driven Acquisition (DDA) began at The University of
Alabama early in 2016, following a thorough review of the GOBI ap-
proval plan. While the original intention of the profile review was to
create a more robust traditional approval plan, the success of demand
driven acquisitions combined with other new initiatives resulted in a
shift away from traditional collection development. Based on nearly
three years of experience working with DDA at The University of
Alabama, this article explores the migration from traditional book
collection development to what could be described as a collection
strategy. The new strategy aims to provide seamless access and delivery
to e-books covering a wide range of the disciplines supported at the
university. The goal is to provide access to as much content as possible
while supporting purchasing based on demonstrated need. This change
is a result of the new strategy to allocate shrinking funds toward re-
sources that are needed now rather than purchasing materials estimated
to be needed in the future. With library budgets tightening, it is critical
to show return on investment and DDA allows the library to offer a
broad range of content, but only purchase items which show usage.
Initiation of the DDA program
DDA began as a pilot project designed to work in tandem with a
traditional print/e-preferred approval plan. The library was still using a
traditional collection development model for books with the approval
plan and librarian selection accounting for the majority of purchases.
The library was not using demand driven acquisition, though librarians
had some experience with similar models, including a recently initiated
evidence-based plan with Wiley and a small selection of titles pur-
chased through R2 Digital Library. With the bulk of purchasing still
based on traditional models, a decision was made in the fall of 2015 to
work with GOBI Library Solutions from EBSCO (GOBI) and librarian
liaisons on a complete review and update of the approval plan profile.
The existing traditional approval plan was managed by GOBI and most
books were received via the plan or firm ordering through GOBI.
The main goal of the review was to expand the profile so that more
relevant monographs would be received automatically, thus reducing
the number of firm order selections. The plan was to make the process
more efficient, though the intent was to keep the traditional model. The
emphasis was on librarian expertise for review of the approval plan
with less time required for title by title selection. During the profile
review, DDA was not being discussed broadly within the library.
However, the impact of an approval plan profile overhaul and how it
would serve to drive DDA was being considered among select man-
agers, as there was not a clear directive in place to pursue DDA. There
had been discussion among key managers beginning in the fall of 2015
regarding a move toward DDA, though no plans were set in motion. A
new Dean of Libraries arrived in January of 2016 and he supported
exploration of DDA. Planning started in full force with a charge to in-
itiate a DDA plan at the earliest possible date.
A new strategy
Key goals were established for DDA implementation, including ef-
ficiency, broad subject coverage, and alignment to the existing tradi-
tional collection development model and its reliance on the approval
plan and librarian selection. Monograph selection and purchasing at
The University of Alabama relied heavily on GOBI. The new DDA plan
aims at efficiency, allowing the process to move from title selection to
discovery to purchase with as little staff intervention as possible. Title
selection is managed by GOBI, based on the comprehensive approval
plan profile. DDA eligible titles on the EBSCO eBooks platform are then
made available to the university community through automatic weekly
updates to EBSCO Discovery. Additional efficiencies were realized in
August 2017 when the library migrated from Serials Solutions to Full
Text Finder. Previous to this migration, staff time was required to ac-
tivate purchased titles in Serials Solutions. The move to Full Text Finder
made that an unnecessary step as EBSCO automatically activates pur-
chased titles in Full Text Finder.
A deposit account funds DDA. This made the process more efficient.
Transactions that would previously have resulted in order, receipt and
payment of individual titles are now handled with one record for DDA
deposit account payments, processed on an as needed basis, combined
with regular purchasing and accounting reports from EBSCO. As of the
date of this article, over 11,000 titles have been purchased in three
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.acalib.2019.03.005
Received 15 March 2019; Accepted 18 March 2019
⁎
Corresponding author.
E-mail addresses: maarthur@ua.edu (M.A. Arthur), srfitzgerald1@ua.edu (S.R. Fitzgerald).
The Journal of Academic Librarianship xxx (xxxx) xxx–xxx
0099-1333/ © 2019 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
Please cite this article as: Michael A. Arthur and Sarah Rose Fitzgerald, The Journal of Academic Librarianship,
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.acalib.2019.03.005