Focaal—Journal of Global and Historical Anthropology 84 (2019): 47–61
© Stichting Focaal and Berghahn Books
doi:10.3167/fcl.2019.840104
“Urban renewal with dancing and music”?
Te renewal machine’s struggle to organize hegemony in Turkey
Cansu Civelek
Abstract: In 2012, an urban renewal project in Eskişehir, Turkey, was initiated
with claims of “festive renewal,” challenging the theories of critical urban studies
that emphasize the disruptive efects of such projects. Built on a discussion about
hegemony, which deploys consent and dissent in its organization, this article eth-
nographically investigates the tactics and strategies of the renewal machine that
mobilized and co-opted parts of the locals into the project while invoking layers
of dissent, distrust, and discomfort. Te article discusses how historically built po-
litical, socioeconomic, and gender inequalities were efciently detected, reconsti-
tuted, and put into the service of the renewal machine while revealing tension and
dynamism behind the “festive renewal.” It shows a fragility of hegemony that is
neither a given nor a completed template.
Keywords: hegemony, renewal machine, Turkey, urban renewal, urban renewal
projects
In the summer of 2012, in one of the remain-
ing gecekondu
1
gardens in the neighborhood
of Karapınar (Eskişehir, Turkey), a group of
women were talking about their future life in
the apartments while drinking tea and watch-
ing the ongoing construction in the urban re-
newal zone. Tey aspired to apartment towers,
which they equated with a “luxurious” lifestyle.
As they thought I must live in an apartment
building, they asked me about the necessities
of what they imagined a “luxurious” life entails.
Tey boasted about their plans for buying new
furniture and clothes despite the cost. A few
weeks later, during one of my meetings at the
Odunpazarı municipality, ruled by the Justice
and Development Party (AKP), the then mayor
2
rehashed the “magical success” of the Karapınar
urban renewal project (URP). Narratives about
the “win-win project,” doubled with “festive re-
newal,” became the trademarks of the Karapınar
URP:
Tink about a situation where everybody
wins. Te hallmark of this project is that
this is a win-win project. Yes, we [the mu-
nicipality] win as we gain political pres-
tige and become a role model for Turkey.
Te TOKİ [Turkish Mass Housing Ad-
ministration] wins as it obtains economic
return and prestige. Our people win as