Determination of Optimal Resistance Spot Welding
Parameter on Low Carbon Steel Welding Quality
Abstract—The welding quality in the form of nugget
diameter and the tensile strength of resistance spot
welding in low carbon steel was experimentally
investigated. Two types of low carbon steel; the uncoated
plate of SPC 270D and the coated plate of SCGA 270D
with the same thickness of 0.7 mm were used and studied
in this experiment. The process determination of optimal
welding conditions was done based on welding current and
welding time for the combination of each material and also
their mixed. This work revealed that both of the weld
current and weld time parameters have a great influence
on the quality of the spot welded joints, in the form of
nugget diameter formation and its corresponding tensile
shear load. The latter is needed to be examined in order to
understand the failure mode of joints. The results which
plotted as graphs and the confirmation by figures are
discussed.
Keywords—Resistance spot welding, welding
parameters, weld nugget diameter, tensile-shear load
I. INTRODUCTION
Resistance Spot Welding (RSW) has a great interest
application in many fabrication industries. Upon of those
industries, automotive industries may become the greatest
applicant towards RSW due to the characteristic of
inexpensive processes, effective way to join the metal sheets
even in the different thickness and also the susceptibility
processes to be automated [1]. Up to 4000 points spot of
RSW, mostly in the form of lap joints can be implemented for
creating a single monocoque body of vehicle. This will
become the particular advantage of using RSW in automated
production lines with high production quantities.
It is become often for automobile maker to improve the
vehicle body to meet the customer needs from the view of
body safety enhancement, weight reduction eco-car, included
providing anti-corrosion guarantees on the body of
automobile. Regarding to the last matter, the use of coated
material (galvanized one) becomes a choice to be
implemented in production lines and the amounts have been
increased significantly to prevent the manufacturer brand
decreases in customer eyes. As the resistance spot welding is
still the dominant welding process for auto body assembly,
which involved both of coated and uncoated steel, therefore it
is necessary to consider the optimal welding parameter to
secure the reliability of structured vehicle white body both in
productivity and quality. This experimental study deals with
the determination of optimal resistance spot welding
parameter both of the coated and uncoated low carbon steel
without causing expulsion. It is generally known that the
expulsion is responsible for the failure of achieving minimal
nugget size and affected the weld strength value due to metal
loss. The result of this study is intended to be used to control
the amount of heat generated from weld current electrical
energy to be transformed into the suitable size of weld nugget
diameter and its strength of the weld joints considering to the
energy saving and financial aspect.
II. MATERIAL AND EXPERIMENT PROCEDURE
2.1 Material
The low carbon steels of material that have been used in
this experiment are the uncoated sheet of SPC 270D and the
coated sheet of SCGA 270D, which are widely used for
automobile bodies. The data of each chemical composition
and mechanical properties of those materials reported by steel
maker supplier (JFE Corp.) can be looked in the Table 1. Each
of those materials in the same thickness of 0.7 mm was cut in
to specimens with the dimension of 110 x 20 mm. The
specimens were then overlapped for the purpose of tensile
shear test with the arrangement like depicted in Fig. 1. This
arrangement will be applied to investigate the optimal welding
parameters for the combination of SPC-SPC, SPC-SCGA and
SCGA-SCGA respectively.
Tota Pirdo Kasih
Department of Industrial Engineering,
Bina Nusantara University, Jl. KH Syahdan No. 9,
Palmerah, Jakarta Barat, Indonesia.
Email: tkasih@binus.edu
Iwan Tutuka Pambudi and Budi Santoso, Production
Technical and Manufacturing Process, Astra
Manufacturing Polytechnic, Jl. Gaya Motor Raya No.8,
Jakarta, Indonesia.
E-mail: itpambudi@yahoo.com and
14330.toso.tpm@gmail.com
The authors wish to thank PT. Astra Daihatsu Motor for supporting the materials and
providing facilities during the research experiments.
2014 2nd International Conference on Technology, Informatics, Management, Engineering & Environment
Bandung, Indonesia, August 19-21, 2014
75 978-1-4799-4805-5/14/$31.00 ©2014 IEEE