Research Article Open Access
Page et al., J Foren Psy 2018, 3:3
Research Article
Journal of Forensic Psychology
J
o
u
r
n
a
l
o
f
F
o
r
e
n
s
i
c
P
s
y
c
h
o
l
o
g
y
ISSN: 2475-319X
Open Access
Volume 3 • Issue 3 • 144
J Foren Psy, an open access journal
ISSN: 2475-319X
The Measurement of Substance Use in Forensic Schizophrenia Spectrum
Disorders-Initial Validation of a New Scale
Louis De Page*, Raphaëlle Boursoit and Pierre Titeca
Clinical Psychologist, Centre Hospitalier Jean Titeca, 11 rue de la Luzerne, 1030 Schaerbeek, Belgium
Abstract
Background: Mainstream substance abuse assessment schemes do not grasp the specifc consequences of
substance abuse (SA) in a) schizophrenia in patients and b) forensic settings. In the current study, we present the
initial validation stages of a new scale measuring substance abuse and its consequences specifcally for schizophrenia
spectrum disorders (SZ) in forensic settings.
Methods: This observer-rated scale was elaborated through clinical observations in a medium-secure forensic
unit for SZ. This 52-item scale measures antecedents, quantitative aspects of the SA, immediate effects, reasons for
use, insight, cessation attitudes, transgressions (e.g. smuggling or extortion) and consequences through all-available
indications. This scale was tested in three groups of forensic patients with SZ (n=112).
Results: We found good internal consistency and interrater agreement estimates, good agreement between our
scale and diagnoses of SA, moderate to strong relations with clinical functioning, risk estimates and psychopathy.
Prevalences reported through this new scale are congruent with international literature. Differential patterns of scores
based on substance(s) being used were observed.
Conclusions: This new scale appeared to grasp for the clinical variety of SA in forensic schizophrenia inpatients
in psychometrically sound way. The instrument appeared to be user-friendly enough not to require specifc training
or long uptake.
Keywords: Schizophrenia; Forensic; Substance use; Cannabis;
Stimulants; Psychosis
Introduction
Te assessment of substance abuse (SA) has generated a
considerable body of literature and a wide array of measures have been
devised. However, when it comes to measuring SA in schizophrenic
subjects in forensic psychiatric settings, it gets more complicated.
Interaction between schizophrenia spectrum disorders (SZ) and SA
has been widely investigated [1]. A generally high prevalence of SA
in SZ has been reported 50% to 86% [2-4]. Several explanations have
been advanced: SA creates a vulnerability for SZ, self-medication for SZ
subjects, reward defciency circuits, etc [1,2].
Clinically, it is generally accepted that SA might alleviate symptoms
in the short term, but worsen the overall course of SZ. Te precise
pattern of the benefts and harm depends on the substances being used.
For example, cocaine alleviates negative symptoms afer recent use [5]
but is associated with more physical health diagnoses, more frequent
mental health admissions, and housing instability [4,6]. Cannabis
alleviates anxious symptoms in the short term, but worsen (positive,
thought disturbance and hostility) SZ symptoms aferwards, and creates
a bidirectional association between the likelihood of SA and symptom
severity in the long run [7]. Beside efects on symptoms, cannabis use
was associated with higher rates of psychotic relapse [8], and appeared
to consolidate transient psychoses into SZ [4,6]. In general, SA in SZ
has also been associated with non-compliance [9] and higher rates of
readmissions [10].
In forensic context, the assessment of SA is especially important
given its precipitating efect for violence [11,12]. Te complex
intertwinement between SZ, SA and violence outreaches the scope
of this article, but diferentiating the pathways to violence is crucial.
Summarily stated: some forensic patients have a longstanding history
of antisocial behavior where SA and SZ came afer the onset of violence
*Corresponding author: Louis De Page, Centre Hospitalier Jean Titeca, 11 rue de
la Luzerne, 1030 Schaerbeek, Belgium
Received July 18, 2018; Accepted July 31, 2018; Published August 13, 2018
Citation: Page LD, Boursoit R, Titeca P (2018) The Measurement of Substance
Use in Forensic Schizophrenia Spectrum Disorders-Initial Validation of a New
Scale. J Foren Psy 3: 144.
Copyright: © 2018 Page LD, et al. This is an open-access article distributed under
the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted
use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and
source are credited.
so called “early starters” [13]. Oppositely, “late starters” have SZ (and
SA) prior to violence. SA might also lead indirectly to criminogenic
environments, which in turns augments the likelihood of violence
which is closer to “early starters” [11]. SA might directly exacerbate
delusions or hostility, diminish the efectiveness of medication, and
lead to violence (which is likelier for “late starters”). Terefore, an
assessment of SA in forensic SZ should record antecedents in order to
diferentiate pathways to violence. Antecedents are closely linked to
behavioral and lifestyle psychopathic traits [14,15].
Monitoring and assessing SA in forensic schizophrenic subjects has
specifc implications that would not be measured in substance-focused
questionnaires. Tese include breaking hospital rules by smuggling
substances, trafcking, jeopardizing treatment progression, augment
violence, etc. In Belgium, as in many other countries, forensic patients
are ofen on conditional release when they enter care and when they
are rehabilitated in community settings. Tis conditional release can
be revoked if SA is detected, or if SA ushers an infringement release
conditions (e.g. violence, skipping probation, etc.).
Aim and formal hypotheses
Our aim is to create a reliable and valid scale assessing substance
use in forensic schizophrenia spectrum patients. Our new scale should
accurately identify SA in SZ patients, and patients identifed as such