68 © JOURNAL OF CIVIL ENGINEERING / Vol. 34 No. 2/ December 2019
SORPTIVITY AND CHLORIDE PENETRABILITY EVALUATION OF
CONCRETE INCORPORATING FLY ASH AND SILICA FUME
Wahyuniarsih Sutrisno
a*
, Gabriel Ghewa
b
, Priyo Suprobo
a
Abstract: Diffusion is one of the the main mechanisms of fluid ingress into the concrete. However, in partially saturated
concrete, the fluid will mainly be absorbed by the capillary suction mechanism, which associates with the sorptivity properties
of the concrete. This paper presents the results of an experimental program to investigate the influence of Portland cement
substitution with Silica Fume (SF) and Type F Fly Ash (FA) on the rate of absorption, which also known as sorptivity, and
chloride penetration of concrete. The sorptivity of the concrete was evaluated according to ASTM 1585, while the chloride
penetration was evaluated according to ASTM C 1202. By substituting part of cement with FA and SF, it was found that the
sorptivity of concrete is reduced. Furthermore, all type of concrete with supplementary material, including CFA, CSF and
CSM, is confirmed to enhance the ability of concrete to resist chloride penetration compared yo normal concrete (NC).
Keywords: Durability, Sorptivity, Chloride Penetrability, Fly Ash and Silica Fume
INTRODUCTION
In the recent decade, durability problems are
becoming a concern to many engineer and researcher.
Many constructions built in the 1900s and even the new
poorly built structure is suffering to damage due to
durability issues. Structures located in the area with the
possibility of water intact, such as the marine
environment, have a direct impact on the durability
problems. In marine structure, the chloride ion is one of
the main problems which can induce the corrosion
problem [1]. In case corrosion induced by chloride, the
passive layer of steel is damage due to chloride attack,
and the corrosion process starts to develop [2], [3]. As the
corrosion starts to develop, the volume of the rust will
increase significantly and causing crack at the interface of
the steel bar of concrete. Over time, the crack will see
growth and reach the concrete surface. This condition will
accelerate the chloride ingress and lead to faster
development of corrosion. By looking at that fact, it is
important to assess the concrete ability to resist chloride
ion penetration to have a deep insight of chloride ion
penetration into the concrete.
The significant problems of early deterioration in the
concrete structures are occurring in structures that
experience frequent environmental changes, such as
cyclic drying and wetting [4]–[7]. As widely known,
water and oxygen are the main factors that can induce the
durability problems such as corrosion. Over a certain
period of time, the frequent environmental changes will
lead to the fluctuation of the effective diffusion
coefficient. Therefore, considering diffusion alone in the
service life modeling is not sufficient for most structures,
and more research is needed to incorporate other
mechanisms, especially sorptivity [4].
Sorptivity is a parameter which associates with the
rate of absorption of the concrete. When the concrete
surface is not saturated at the specific time and it is
exposed to a chloride solution, the capillary tension will
absorb the water and chloride solution into the concrete.
Over time, this condition will affect the pore structure of
the concrete and causing durability problems. The pore
structure mostly depending on the fluid penetration
capacity of concrete which known as permeability [8].
Concrete with high permeability tends to absorb more
water which leads to the introduction of molecules that
react and destroy its chemical stability[9]. However,
lower permeability of concrete can improve the durability
performance of concrete by improving the penetration of
water, chloride, sulfate, and other harmful substances
[10]. Therefore, it is necessary to assess the fluid entrance
rate into the concrete and one of the popular methods that
can be used to assess this property of concrete is the rate
of absorption or also known as sorptivity.
Besides frequent environmental changes, another
factor that can affect the rate of diffusion and absorption
of the concrete is the quality of the concrete material.
Several researchers found that the raw material and
quality of concrete material really affect the durability of
concrete [11]–[13] including the rate of diffusion and
absorption of the concrete. The concrete-based on
Portland cement is the most widely used material in the
world. Compared to other materials like steel, aluminum
and plastics, it is the most viable option for the
construction industry considering economic and
environmental costs. However, the production of cement
is very energy-intensive and releases a significant volume
of CO
2
. To overcome this problem, many researchers
used supplementary material to substitute the amount of
cement used for concrete.
In recent years, fly ash, silica fume and blast furnace
slag are the popular material for substituting cement or
known as the supplementary material [10], [14]–[18]. Fly
ash and silica fume are the waste product of the industrial
processes. Fly ash is a by-product of coal-burning power
plants and silica fume is produced by reducing the high-
purity quartz with coal in electric arc furnaces in the
manufactures of silicon and ferrosilicon alloys. The
amount of this waste material is increasing rapidly every
a
Lecturer in the Civil Engineering Department, Institut Teknologi
Sepuluh Nopember, ITS Campus, Sukolilo, Surabaya 60111, Indonesia.
Corresponding author email address: niar1206@gmail.com
b
Graduate Student in the Civil Engineering Department, Institut
Teknologi Sepuluh Nopember, ITS Campus, Sukolilo, Surabaya 60111,
Indonesia.
brought to you by CORE View metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk
provided by Center for Scientific Publication