Water Footprint of European Cars: Potential Impacts of Water
Consumption along Automobile Life Cycles
Markus Berger,*
,†
Jens Warsen,
‡
Stephan Krinke,
‡
Vanessa Bach,
†
and Matthias Finkbeiner
†
†
Technische Universitä t Berlin, Department of Environmental Technology, Chair of Sustainable Engineering, Office Z1, Strasse des
17. Juni 135, 10623 Berlin, Germany
‡
Volkswagen AG, Group Research, Environmental Affairs Product, P.O. Box 011/1774, 38436 Wolfsburg, Germany
* S Supporting Information
ABSTRACT: Due to global increase of freshwater scarcity, knowledge
about water consumption in product life cycles is important. This study
analyzes water consumption and the resulting impacts of Volkswagen’s car
models Polo, Golf, and Passat and represents the first application of impact-
oriented water footprint methods on complex industrial products.
Freshwater consumption throughout the cars’ life cycles is allocated to
material groups and assigned to countries according to import mix shares or
location of production sites. Based on these regionalized water inventories,
consequences for human health, ecosystems, and resources are determined
by using recently developed impact assessment methods. Water
consumption along the life cycles of the three cars ranges from 52 to 83
m
3
/car, of which more than 95% is consumed in the production phase,
mainly resulting from producing iron, steel, precious metals, and polymers.
Results show that water consumption takes place in 43 countries worldwide
and that only 10% is consumed directly at Volkswagen’s production sites.
Although impacts on health tend to be dominated by water consumption in
South Africa and Mozambique, resulting from the production of precious
metals and aluminum, consequences for ecosystems and resources are
mainly caused by water consumption of material production in Europe.
■
INTRODUCTION
“Yet Another Footprint to Worry About: Water” was a headline
in The Wall Street Journal
1
with regard to the foundation of the
Water Footprint Network
2
in 2008, which published
surprisingly high figures of 70 L virtual water consumption
3
per apple or 2700 L per cotton T-shirt. Starting from such
volumetric tools, which simply aggregate consumptions of
ground and surface water (blue water), soil moisture (green
water
4
), and volumes of polluted freshwater (gray water),
substantial methodological developments were undertaken
recently. Modern impact-oriented water footprinting methods,
which were reviewed in a previous work,
5
characterize water
consumption based on parameters such as local scarcity or
sensitivity of population and ecosystems and model complex
impact pathways. However, these methods were hardly tested
or applied in complex industrial product systems. So far, most
water footprint studies published focus on agricultural products
such as food,
6,7
natural fibers,
8,9
or bioenergy
10
and biofuels.
11
Volkswagen has been analyzing the environmental effects of its
cars and components by means of life cycle assessment
(LCA)
12,13
for many years.
14
However, due to lack of data and
appropriate impact assessment models, the consumption of
freshwater has not yet been considered.
Therefore, the aim of this study is to analyze freshwater
consumption along the life cycles of three Volkswagen car
models on both inventory and impact assessment levels. First,
regionalized water inventories are determined, showing
country-specific water consumption figures, for the Polo 1.2
turbocharged direct injection (TDI), Golf 1.6 TDI, and Passat
2.0 TDI (model year 2010). Based on these inventories, seven
impact assessment methods, which represent different levels of
sophistication and model different impact pathways, are
applied. Further objectives comprise the discussion and
comparison of impact assessment results, the identification of
significant life cycle stages and processes, and the analysis of
sensitivity of results to altered regionalization scenarios. Finally,
the potential damages resulting from water consumption are
compared to damages caused by other environmental
interferences, such as resource use and emissions, in order to
estimate the relevance of water for the automotive industry.
Received: November 9, 2011
Revised: January 28, 2012
Accepted: March 5, 2012
Published: March 5, 2012
Article
pubs.acs.org/est
© 2012 American Chemical Society 4091 dx.doi.org/10.1021/es2040043 | Environ. Sci. Technol. 2012, 46, 4091-4099