Updating the neural network sediment load models using
different sensitivity analysis methods: a regional
application
Reza Asheghi, Seyed Abbas Hosseini, Mojtaba Saneie and
Abbas Abbaszadeh Shahri
ABSTRACT
The amount of transported sediment load by streams is a vital but high nonlinear dynamic process in
water resources management. In the current paper, two optimum predictive models subjected to
artificial neural network (ANN) were developed. The employed inputs were then prioritized using
diverse sensitivity analysis (SA) methods to address new updated but more efficient ANN structures.
The models were found through the 263 processed datasets of three rivers in Idaho, USA using nine
different measured flow and sediment variables (e.g., channel geometry, geomorphology, hydraulic)
for a period of 11 years. The used parameters were selected based on the prior knowledge of the
conventional analyses in which the effect of suspended load on bed load was also investigated.
Analyzed accuracy performances using different criteria exhibited improved predictability in updated
models which can lead to an advanced understanding of used parameters. Despite different SA
methods being employed in evaluating model parameters, almost similar results were observed and
then verified using relevant sensitivity indices. It was demonstrated that the ranked parameters using
SA due to covering more uncertainties can be more reliable. Evaluated models using sensitivity
indices showed that contribution of suspended load on predicted bed load is not significant.
Reza Asheghi
Seyed Abbas Hosseini (corresponding author)
Mojtaba Saneie
Abbas Abbaszadeh Shahri
Department of Civil Engineering, Science and
Research Branch,
Islamic Azad University,
Tehran,
Iran
E-mail: abbas_hoseyni@srbiau.ac.ir
Key words | artificial neural network, sensitivity analysis, transported sediment loads,
updated model
INTRODUCTION
The transported sediments by rivers as a complicated set of
processes between stream flow, geologic, geomorphic, and
organic factors is an important but critical regionally
specific concern in the hydrological perspective to realize
how rivers work (e.g., Melesse et al. ; Hajbabaei et al.
; Sari et al. ; Jin et al. ). Such sediments can be
very informative in assessment of engineering purposes
(e.g., channels, reservoirs, and dams), geo-environmental
and ecosystem impacts (e.g., protection of fish and wildlife
habitats), and river basin management (e.g., soil erosion,
transported sediments, and pollutants) (e.g., Kisi et al. ;
Bouzeria et al. ; Jin et al. ). Thereby, prediction of
sediment loads has become an important issue in many
countries in introducing schemes for river water monitoring.
Modeling approaches are the common way to estimate
transported sediment loads. However, the effects of the
involved parameters due to model structure, hydrological,
time-series inputs, geological, geomorphological, hydrologi-
cal and hydraulic features on predicted sediment loads
should be considered. The wide variety of involved par-
ameters exhibit no accepted universal approach to predict
all types of sediment loads (Ma et al. ; Leimgruber
et al. ; Asheghi & Hosseini ). This indicates why
several modeling tools for simulating sediment loads have
562 © IWA Publishing 2020 Journal of Hydroinformatics | 22.3 | 2020
doi: 10.2166/hydro.2020.098
Downloaded from http://iwaponline.com/jh/article-pdf/22/3/562/693089/jh0220562.pdf
by guest
on 07 March 2023