IFAC PapersOnLine 50-1 (2017) 14137–14142
ScienceDirect ScienceDirect
Available online at www.sciencedirect.com
2405-8963 © 2017, IFAC (International Federation of Automatic Control) Hosting by Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Peer review under responsibility of International Federation of Automatic Control.
10.1016/j.ifacol.2017.08.1856
© 2017, IFAC (International Federation of Automatic Control) Hosting by Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Keywords: direct normal irradiance, fractional cloud cover, clear-sky index, concentrating solar
power, adaptive network-based fuzzy inference system.
1. INTRODUCTION
Forecasting the solar resource using a sky imager, due to
the ability of such device to provide a detailed cartography
of the sky, is gaining interest at a fast pace. However, for
now, only a few studies are dedicated to forecasting Direct
Normal Irradiance (DNI) using sky-imaging data. Keep in
mind that DNI (I ), which can be defined as the direct
irradiance received on a plane normal to the Sun, can be
split into two terms, i.e. clear-sky DNI (I
cs
) and the clear-
sky index (k
c
) (1):
I = I
cs
· k
c
(1)
I
cs
is about the solar power received at ground level per
unit of area, at a specific location, when there is no cloud
occulting the Sun. k
c
is derived from the attenuation of
clear-sky DNI caused by clouds.
These few studies have been conducted by a group of
researchers belonging to the University of California in
San Diego (UCSD). First, Marquez and Coimbra proposed
in 2013 a deterministic forecasting model for DNI based
on the cloud cover estimated in a region of the sky with
potentially sun-blocking clouds (Marquez and Coimbra,
2013). In this model, clear-sky DNI is supposed to be
constant (I
cs
= 900 W m
-2
) during the time interval of
interest (i.e. from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m.). The forecast horizon
is up to 15 minutes ahead. Cloud pixels are identified by
using the hybrid algorithm developed by Li et al. (Li et
al., 2011) whereas cloud motion is estimated using the
PIV (Particle Image Velocimetry) method (Marquez and
Coimbra, 2013). Clearly, performance is degraded by not
taking changes in I
cs
into consideration. Following this
first study, a new (deterministic) forecasting model for
DNI has been developed by the Coimbra’s group (Chu et
al., 2013). The forecast horizon is up to 10 minutes ahead.
I
cs
is estimated using a 8th-order polynomial of the cosine
of the Solar Zenith Angle (SZA). Note that a 3rd-order
polynomial has proven to do the trick. Both the cloud map
and cloud motion are estimated in the same way Marquez
and Coimbra have done (Marquez and Coimbra, 2013).
In addition, a hybrid forecasting model that makes use of
two artificial neural networks has been developed: the first
neural network is used in case of high variability whereas
the second one is used when variability is low. The authors
highlight that two artificial neural networks, instead of
only one network dealing with all types of variability, allow
DNI to be forecasted with much better accuracy. The
cloud cover in regions of the sky having great potential for
affecting ground DNI values as well as last-minute values
of DNI are serving as model inputs. Only data that agrees
with the following condition are considered: cos(SZA) <
0.6, that is to say SZA 53
◦
. As a result, DNI is forecasted
when the Sun is near the zenith. In that case, perspective
effects are lower. A short time afterwards, a novel method
for cloud tracking that makes use of TSI images to forecast
DNI up to 20 minutes ahead is presented (Quesada-Ruiz et
al., 2014). Cloud pixels are identified by using the hybrid
algorithm developed by Li et al. (Li et al., 2011) and I
cs
is computed from a 8th-order polynomial of the cosine
of the solar zenith angle. The authors introduce both a
sector method to detect the motion of potentially sun-
blocking clouds and an adjustable-ladder method, which
is based on a size-adjustable set of grid elements that
focus on sky regions of greatest potential for affecting
ground DNI values. The model performs better than when
∗
PROMES-CNRS (UPR 8521),
Tecnosud, Rambla de la thermodynamique, 66100 Perpignan, France
∗∗
University of Perpignan Via Domitia,
52 Avenue Paul Alduy, 66860 Perpignan, France
Tel.: +33468682257; e-mail: stephane.grieu@promes.cnrs.fr
Abstract: In a context of sustainable development, interest for Concentrating Solar Power
(CSP) is growing rapidly. One of the most challenging topics is to improve solar resource
assessment and forecasting in order to optimize power plant operation. Indeed, in CSP plants,
electricity generation is directly impacted by both availability and variability of the solar resource
and, more specifically, by Direct Normal Irradiance (DNI). Moreover, in the framework of
the CSPIMP research project, PROMES-CNRS has developped a sky imager able to provide
High Dymanic Range (HDR) images. As a result, the present paper deals with the short-
term forecasting of DNI using sky-imaging data. Preliminary results highlight that models (in
particular based on artificial intelligence tools) that make use of the fractional cloud cover have
the potential to outperform persistence models in terms of forecasting accuracy.
Julien Nou
∗
Rémi Chauvin
∗
Julien Eynard
∗,∗∗
Stéphane Thil
∗,∗∗
Stéphane Grieu
∗,∗∗
Towards the short-term forecasting of direct
normal irradiance using a sky imager