Measuring the satisfaction of intensive care unit patient families in
Morocco: A regression tree analysis*
Nada Damghi, MD; Ibtissam Khoudri, MD; Latifa Oualili, MD; Khalid Abidi, MD; Naoufel Madani, MD;
Amine Ali Zeggwagh, MD, PhD; Redouane Abouqal, MD, PhD
I
n critical care, the quality of care
has traditionally focused on the
provider, the process of care, and
patient outcomes (1). Critical ill-
ness and subsequent hospitalization in an
intensive care unit (ICU) often occur
without any warning, leaving little time
for patients or their families to prepare. It
is a catastrophic event for families, creating
emotional upsets, anxiety, uncertainty, and
fear of losing a loved one. ICU physicians
have then to be concerned not only with
patients’ health status, but also with the
psychosocial needs of their families.
Because the family members often un-
dergo psychologic crises, numerous studies
(1–13) from both the United States and
Europe have documented the needs of fam-
ily members of critically ill patients. The
family needs are acknowledged as a priority
of ICU physicians or nurses and an initial
step in providing appropriate care for both
families and patients (1–3).
Psychologic assurance from ICU physi-
cians has been shown to induce a sense of
being cared for along with a sense of secu-
rity and hope in families undergoing a life
crisis. Healthcare professionals are then
asked to provide clear and appropriate in-
formation to involve the family members in
making decisions about patients in the ICU.
The results of studies (1–13) suggested that
information-giving is one of the most effec-
tive means of communication and the cor-
nerstone of successful crisis intervention
with families of patients in ICUs. Family
satisfaction increases with clear informa-
tion. Also, in some cases, the need for hope,
reassurance, and proximity to the patient
seems as important as the need for com-
munication.
Several questionnaires have been de-
veloped to measure the satisfaction of
patients’ family members (1, 14 –16).
The Society of Critical Care Medicine’s
Family Needs Assessment questionnaire
*See also p. 2204.
From the Medical Intensive Care Unit (ND, IK, LO,
KA, NM, AAZ, RA), Ibn Sina University Hospital, Rabat,
Morocco; and the Laboratory of Biostatistics, Clinical
and Epidemiological Research (AAZ, RA), Faculty of
Medicine, Rabat, Morocco.
The authors have not disclosed any potential con-
flicts of interest.
ND and IK contributed equally to this work.
For information regarding this article, E-mail:
abouqal@invivo.edu
Copyright © 2008 by the Society of Critical Care
Medicine and Lippincott Williams & Wilkins
DOI: 10.1097/CCM.0b013e31817c104e
Objective: Meeting the needs of patients’ family members
becomes an essential part of responsibilities of intensive care unit
physicians. The aim of this study was to evaluate the satisfaction
of patients’ family members using the Arabic version of the
Society of Critical Care Medicine’s Family Needs Assessment
questionnaire and to assess the predictors of family satisfaction
using the classification and regression tree method.
Design: The authors conducted a prospective study.
Setting: This study was conducted at a 12-bed medical inten-
sive care unit in Morocco.
Patients: Family representatives (n 194) of consecutive
patients with a length of stay >48 hrs were included in the study.
Intervention: Intervention was the Society of Critical Care
Medicine’s Family Needs Assessment questionnaire.
Measurements and Main Results: Demographic data for rela-
tives included age, gender, relationship with patients, education
level, and intensive care unit commuting time. Clinical data for
patients included age, gender, diagnoses, intensive care unit
length of stay, Acute Physiology and Chronic Health Evaluation,
MacCabe index, Therapeutic Interventioning Scoring System, and
mechanical ventilation. The Arabic version of the Society of Crit-
ical Care Medicine’s Family Needs Assessment questionnaire was
administered between the third and fifth days after admission. Of
family representatives, 81% declared being satisfied with infor-
mation provided by physicians, 27% would like more information
about the diagnosis, 30% about prognosis, and 45% about treat-
ment. In univariate analysis, family satisfaction (small Society of
Critical Care Medicine’s Family Needs Assessment questionnaire
score) increased with a lower family education level (p .005),
when the information was given by a senior physician (p .014),
and when the Society of Critical Care Medicine’s Family Needs
Assessment questionnaire was administered by an investigator
(p .002). Multivariate analysis (classification and regression
tree) showed that the education level was the predominant factor
contributing to the Society of Critical Care Medicine’s Family
Needs Assessment questionnaire score. Society of Critical Care Med-
icine’s Family Needs Assessment questionnaire increased (greater
satisfaction) with a higher education level. Other factors of great
satisfaction included the senior physician providing the information,
and Acute Physiology and Chronic Health Evaluation <15.
Conclusions: Satisfaction of intensive care unit patients’ fam-
ilies in a Moroccan sample using the classification and regression
tree was dependent on relatives’ education level, communication
presented by senior caregiver, and low Acute Physiology and
Chronic Health Evaluation score. These data underline cultural
specificities of the study and suggest that caregivers should
develop structured communication programs considering satis-
faction predictors. (Crit Care Med 2008; 36:2084 –2091)
KEY WORDS: critical care; family needs; satisfaction; Arabic
version; Society of Critical Care Medicine’s Family Needs Assess-
ment; tree-based analysis
2084 Crit Care Med 2008 Vol. 36, No. 7