A SciTechnol Journal Research Article
Bellar et al., J Athl Enhanc 2018, 7:5
DOI: 10.4172/2324-9080.1000304
Journal of Athletic
Enhancement
All articles published in Journal of Athletic Enhancement are the property of SciTechnol, and is protected by copyright laws.
Copyright © 2018, SciTechnol, All Rights Reserved.
International Publisher of Science,
Technology and Medicine
The Effects of a Botanical
Blend on Post-Exercise Mucosal
Antimicrobial Proteins
Bellar D
1
*, Aldret RA
1
and Judge LW
2
Abstract
Exercise is a stressor that is known to in some cases suppress
antimicrobial protein levels, particularly secretory immunoglobulin
type A (IgA). Athletes in the midst of in-season training often
demonstrate declining levels of sIgA as well as increased risk for
ailments such as upper respiratory tract infections. Therefore, it
is important to investigate natural supplements that may enhance
post exercise mucosal immune function. Twenty healthy college-
aged males volunteered to participate in the present single blind,
repeated measures study. Three treatments were administered
(botanical spray, botanical drops, placebo) at the onset of 30 Min of
80% VO
2
max cycle ergometer exercise. Secretory IgA and Human
Alpha Defensin were quantifed in saliva samples 30 Min and 90 Min
post exercise. Analysis via repeated measures Anova revealed a
signifcant treatment effect at 30 min (p=0.030) with post hoc testing
revealing a difference between the botanical spray and placebo
(p=0.027), but by 90 Min there was no differences by treatment
(p=0.758). There was no difference by treatment observed at either
30 or 90 Min for human alpha defensin concentrations. Based upon
these preliminary data, it appears that a single dose of the tested
botanical blend delivered via mouth spray can increase sIgA, one
of the primary anti-microbial proteins in the oral cavity, for a short
time post exercise.
Keywords
Secretory IgA; Human alpha defensing; Aerobic training
*Corresponding author: David Bellar Ph. D, Director-School of Kinesiology,
University of Louisiana at Lafayette, USA, Tel: (337) 482-6615; Fax: (337) 482-
6278; E-mail: dbellar@louisiana.edu
Received: August 13, 2018 Accepted: November 12, 2018 Published:
November 19, 2018
Introduction
Exercise is a known stressor that has infuence over many diferent
physiological systems in the body. Tere is evidence in the literature
that long-term training in athletes can negatively afect antimicrobial
protein levels in the oral cavity [1]. Furthermore, it has been reported
that athletes face a higher incidence of upper respiratory tract infection
(URTI) compared to more sedentary individuals [2]. Based upon the
reports in the literature, it is understood that long-term training for
sport performance is a stressor that can both elevate physiological
potential for in the athletic arena, but may depress function in other
system. Moreira et al. [3] reported that a 2-week detraining period
afer a competitive soccer season attenuated secretory IgA (sIgA)
suppression and symptomology of URTI due to training. From this
study it can be suggested that mucosal immunity can quickly rebound
if rest and recovery are allowed for athletic populations. However,
with the demands placed upon athletes, reduced mucosal immunity
and risk for URTI are likely to remain an issue into the future.
It has also been determined by previous research that certain
forms of acute athletic performance and exercise have the ability to
suppress immunoglobulin secretion in the oral cavity [4-6]. However,
most of these exercises are long duration and aerobic, the evidence
for the changes in antimicrobial protein with short-term intermittent
exercise is less clear with some evidence suggesting no change in
immunoglobulin type A [7]. Additionally, Li and Gleeson [8] reported
that 60% VO
2
max cycling for 2 hours did not negatively impact sIgA
secretion rates. However, MacKinnon and Jenkins [9] had previously
reported a decline in sIgA with intense interval exercise (0.075 g
*
kg
-1
)
on a cycle ergometer. Tough there is much study yet needed to fully
elucidate the responses of antimicrobial proteins in the saliva with
all forms of exercise there is enough evidence that further study is
warranted particularly regarding methods to increase antimicrobial
protein levels. Additionally, recreational exercisers represent a larger
population overall as compared to athletes and are engaged in exercise
to beneft health and wellness. If these individual are experiencing
reductions in anti-microbial protein levels any potential treatment
would be benefcial for a large number of persons.
Some botanicals, such as baker’s yeast beta glucan, have been
shown to increase sIgA in saliva and help decrease symptoms of cold
and fu post exercise [10]. Shiitake mushrooms are another natural
food substance that is known to contain beta glucans, which may
be benefcial for human health [11]. Shiitake mushrooms have been
demonstrated to have anti-oxidant activity post exercise, but no
evidence currently exists to examine changes in oral anti-microbial
protein levels post exercise [12]. Terefore, the purpose of this initial
investigation was to examine the efects of a botanical supplement on
secretory immunoglobulin A and alpha defensing levels post-exercise.
Methods
Te study was a within subjects, repeated measures, single blind,
placebo controlled, cross-over design. Afer initial data collection
for anthropometrics and maximum aerobic capacity, subjects were
randomly assigned an order of treatments. Te treatments consisted
of two administration methods of the botanical product and a saline
placebo solution. Te subjects engaged in exercise sessions afer the
administration of each treatment and saliva samples were taken at 30
minute and 90 Min post exercise to examine antimicrobial protein
levels of secretory IgA and human alpha defensing (NHP1-3).
Subjects
For the study 20 apparently healthy male subjects were recruited
to participate (Table 1). Te subjects gave written informed consent
prior to initiating the study. Te institutional review board at the
University of Louisiana at Lafayette approved the study methods.
Initial lab visit
On the frst visit the subjects had basic anthropometric information
collected, followed by the administration of the Leisure and Physical
Activity survey to determine exercise and sedentary habits (Table 2)
[13-15]. Height and weight was collected via a standard triple beam