PHYSICAL REVIEW B 83, 245117 (2011)
Thermoelectric evidence for high-field anomalies in the hidden order phase of URu
2
Si
2
Liam Malone,
1
Tatsuma D. Matusda,
2,3
Arlei Antunes,
4
Georg Knebel,
2
Valentin Taufour,
2
Dai Aoki,
2
Kamran Behnia,
5
Cyril Proust,
1
and Jacques Flouquet
2
1
Laboratoire National des Champs Magn´ etiques Intenses, UPR 3228 (CNRS-INSA-UJF-UPS), Toulouse F-31400, France
2
INAC, SPSMS, CEA Grenoble, 17 Rue des Martyrs, F-38054 Grenoble, France
3
ASRC, Japan Atomic Energy Agency, Tokai, Ibaraki 319-1195, JAPAN
4
LNCMI, CNRS, 25 Rue des Martyrs, F-38042 Grenoble, France
5
Laboratoire Photons Et Matirere (UPMC-CNRS), ESPCI, F-75005 Paris, France
(Received 20 December 2010; revised manuscript received 9 May 2011; published 22 June 2011)
Measurements of the thermoelectric coefficients of URu
2
Si
2
in a high magnetic field could imply topological
Fermi surface changes even deep inside the hidden order state. A change is observed in the thermopower as
a function of the field applied parallel to the easy axis of magnetization, which could signify a change in the
Fermi surface characteristics. The maximum of the thermopower coincides with previously measured anomalies
in resistivity at H
∗
= 23 T. We analyze our results in terms of a Lifshitz transition in URu
2
Si
2
originating from
the hidden order Pauli depairing on a given subband.
DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevB.83.245117 PACS number(s): 71.27.+a, 74.70.Tx
I. INTRODUCTION
At T
0
∼ 17 K, URu
2
Si
2
undergoes a second order phase
transition into a hidden order (HO) state.
1
This transition
demonstrates a large drop in entropy, but to date no order
parameter has been conclusively observed. There are various
theoretical suggestions
2–8
for the hidden order parameter.
Transport and thermodynamic probes point to a significant
Fermi surface reconstruction at T
0
(Refs. 9–11), which leads
to a large drop in carrier density. This decrease in carrier
density corresponds to a decreased Fermi temperature and
furthermore this weakness is reinforced by the large effective
mass of the quasiparticles. Thus a moderate magnetic field
(H ) field can have a large effect on the Fermi surface
characteristics. In addition, a magnetic field, applied parallel to
the c axis, suppresses the hidden order and induces a cascade
of transitions above 35 T (Ref. 12) ending with a paramagnetic
metal above 40 T. Recent resistivity and Hall measurements
13
on high-quality single crystals have revealed anomalies and
additional quantum oscillation frequencies at H
∗
∼ 23 T
implying additional structure in the HO phase or even a
possible phase transition. Thermodynamic measurements
14,15
show no evidence of anomalies in this field range. This
may point to a more subtle topological change in the Fermi
surface or “Lifshitz transition.” If this is the case then the
interplay between the Fermi surface, the HO order parameter
and magnetic field could lead to fascinating insights into this
compound and a better understanding of Fermi surface changes
in the presence of strong correlations.
Measurements of the thermoelectric coefficients at low
temperature can provide valuable information of the Fermi
surface characteristics. Measurements of thermoelectric power
on compounds such as CeColn
5
(Ref. 16) and YbRh
2
Si
2
(Ref. 17) have helped elucidate the nature of the electronic
state. In the case of URu
2
Si
2
, previous measurements have
concentrated on a large increase in the thermoelectric power
and Nernst signal on entering the hidden order state,
10,18
which
is a result of the Fermi surface reconstruction and on the
non-Fermi liquid-like behavior observed for currents applied
along the a axis.
19
However, no previous study has combined
low temperature and high field to study H
∗
. Since Lifshitz
20
first proposed the “2.5” type transition, there have been several
theoretical
21,22
and experimental studies
23
of thermopower
around a topological transition which show the thermopower
is very sensitive to Fermi surface changes. An early proof
of this has been given in a study of CeRu
2
Si
2
through its
pseudometamagnetic transition.
24
Recent measurements of
thermopower
25
on the high temperature cuprates are another
example of this and have provided evidence for previously
unexpected changes in the Fermi surface.
Figure 1 shows a schematic temperature-field phase di-
agram for URu
2
Si
2
when the field is applied along the
c axis.
15,26–28
The hidden order state can be suppressed with a
field of 35 T. At this point several unknown phases (possibly
due to the quantum critical point created when suppressing the
HO state to T = 0) are observed and then at higher fields a
paramagnetic metal is recovered. Recent resistivity and Hall
measurements at low temperatures (down to 250 mK) show
anomalies at H
∗
∼ 23 T (Ref. 13).
Several transport studies of the Fermi surface of
URu
2
Si
2
have been performed.
26,29–31
However, despite recent
progress
31
they cannot account for the correlated Sommerfeld
coefficient observed by heat capacity, implying there are still
some unobserved Fermi surface branches. The angle depen-
dence of the frequencies implies a roughly isotropic Fermi tem-
perature. Angle-resolved photoemission experiments
32
report
a significant Fermi surface change through T
0
due to the heavy
electron bands crossing the Fermi surface, in good agreement
with a symmetry change inside the tetragonal class.
2,3,8,31
In this paper we report measurements of the thermopower
of URu
2
Si
2
in magnetic fields up to 28 T to observe H
∗
.A
change in thermopower is observed approaching H
∗
when the
field is applied along the c axis of the tetragonal crystal. These
results could be explained by a field-induced Lifshitz transition
at H
∗
originating from a specific sheet of the Fermi surface.
Complimentary measurements with the field applied along the
a axis show little change as a function of field. This raises
245117-1 1098-0121/2011/83(24)/245117(5) ©2011 American Physical Society