1 3
DOI 10.1007/s10337-017-3315-1
Chromatographia
SHORT COMMUNICATION
Static Headspace GC/MS Method for Determination of Methanol
and Ethanol Contents, as the Degradation Markers of Solid
Insulation Systems of Power Transformers
Hoda Molavi
1
· Abbas Yousefpour
1
· Akbar Mirmostafa
2
· Ali Sabzi
3
·
Sepideh Hamedi
4
· Milad Narimani
1
· Nazanin Abdi
1
Received: 22 November 2016 / Revised: 7 April 2017 / Accepted: 19 April 2017
© Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2017
issues for utilities. Therefore, considering an appropriate
diagnostic method is essential to prevent unexpected fail-
ures and improve the reliability of the equipment.
It is more than a century that cellulose, a natural poly-
mer containing alpha-D-glucose units, together with min-
eral oil is being employed in transformers as the insulating
system [1]. Plenitude in the nature, good mechanical and
electrical characteristics, along with its ease of use in fabri-
cating operation led to cellulose wide application [1].
Due to the fact that the solid insulation system cannot
be easily replaced as the insulating oil, the age of a trans-
former is evaluated by the health of its solid insulation [2,
3]. Indeed, the extent of insulation paper degradation is
determinative of the remaining life of a solid insulation and
subsequently a transformer [4].
A factor to evaluate the age and the quality of the cel-
lulose insulator is degree of polymerization (DP). This
direct technique is one of the most important tools to
evaluate the lifetime of the paper. New paper has a DP
value of about 1200, which would be reduced to 1000
after applying the drying process, while the water content
is about 0.5%. Reaching a DP value of 200 means that
the tensile strength of the paper has decreased to 20% of
its original value and the transformer life is over [5–7].
Although the measurement of paper’s DP (according to
IEC 60450 [8] or ASTM D4243 [9]), as a direct way, pro-
vides useful information, but it is impossible to access
internal insulation for paper sampling during transformer
regular operation [2].
Utilities are interested in indirect and non-destructive
diagnostic methods for determination of the residual life of
their power transformers, which could be applied easily for
an operating transformer. One of the non-destructive diag-
nostic techniques is using chemical markers, such as car-
bon dioxides and furanic derivations, in the oil.
Abstract Methanol in insulating oil has been proposed as
a new marker for condition assessment of the solid insu-
lation system of power transformers. In the current work,
as a first step of using the new marker, an analytical static
headspace gas chromatography/mass spectrometry method
has been developed, optimized, and validated to measure
methanol and ethanol contents in the insulating mineral
oil. The analyzing setup consists of a 6890 N gas chroma-
tograph equipped with a 5973 network mass spectrometer
(MS) in the absence of a costly headspace autosampler,
and the chromatography separation was performed on a
60 m × 320 μm × 0.5 μm VF-WAXms GC column. Cali-
bration curves have been provided using several concen-
trations of the alcohols, and also limit of detection (LOD),
limit of quantification (LOQ), and relative standard devia-
tion percentage (RSD%) have been determined.
Keywords Gas chromatography · Static headspace · Oil
analysis · Methanol · Insulating paper · Paper degradation ·
Power transformer
Introduction
Power transformers are vital equipment in electrical net-
works, and their health and life expectancy are important
* Hoda Molavi
hmolavi@nri.ac.ir
1
Niroo Research Institute, Tehran, Iran
2
Zangan Industrial Oil Refining Company, Zanjan, Iran
3
Oil and Fuel Laboratory, Niroo Research Institute, Tehran,
Iran
4
Shahid Beheshti University, Tehran, Iran