Microelectronics Reliability 148 (2023) 115162
Available online 12 August 2023
0026-2714/© 2023 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Microelectronics Reliability
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/microrel
TIMs for transfer molded power modules: Characterization, reliability, and
modeling
Alessandro Sitta
a,∗
, Giuseppe Mauromicale
a
, Giuseppe Luigi Malgioglio
a
,
Davide Maria Amoroso
a,b
, Biagio Schifano
b
, Michele Calabretta
a
, Gaetano Sequenzia
b
a
Automotive and Discrete Group, R&D, STMicroelectronics, Stradale Primosole 50, Catania, 95121, Italy
b
University of Catania, Viale Andrea Doria 6, Catania, 95125, Italy
ARTICLE INFO
Keywords:
Thermal interface material
Power cycle
Thermal simulation
Power packages
ABSTRACT
This work presents an integrated experimental–numerical method to characterize, model, and experimentally
study the properties of transfer molded power modules, considering two different thermal interface materials
(TIMs). More specifically, a thermal grease and a phase change material are considered. The aim is to select the
most reliable solution by making analytical characterization and power cycling tests on the modules equipped
with the two kinds of TIMs. Then, further reliability study is accomplished, in order to estimate the lifetime of
the power module equipped with the best TIM, that is the phase change one. Finally, a finite-element numerical
model is developed and correlated with experimental data.
1. Introduction
Energy consumption is one of the leading players in the world
scenario. The need to reduce consumption and emissions has enabled
the development of power electronic devices such as power modules,
which use semiconductors to convert and control electrical energy [1,
2]. In this context, power modules can embed different chips in smaller
area than discrete packages, creating the desired electric topology
with optimized parasitic inductive elements and higher converter’s
efficiency [3].
In addition, power density increases and, consequently, more ther-
momechanical stress is generated. In this framework, reliability is of
paramount importance for evaluating the performance of a power mod-
ule [4–6]. Dedicated processes, like silver sintering, have developed
in order to fulfill extreme reliability requests [7–10]. Various tests are
needed to estimate the lifetime of the device during its mission profile
and thus to predict when the device might fail according to different
possible mechanisms.
One key aspect is the study of the stress generated on power module
interconnections by cyclic temperature swings [11]. This condition is
particularly crucial in the thermal management of electronics [12], as
excessive thermal resistances between junction and environment can
cause high temperatures that can adversely affect performance and
reliability of the power devices [13,14]. The power cycle (PC) test
is related to the study of the reliability of the interconnections, by
accelerated stress conditions. The aim of this experiment is to mimic
∗
Corresponding author.
E-mail address: alessandro.sitta@st.com (A. Sitta).
the thermal fatigue of module’s interfaces generated by temperature
swing that occur during typical operations. According to AQG 324
guideline [15], there exist PC
SEC
and PC
MIN
, depending on the on
time (
) considered for the conduction. PC
SEC
involves the chip-near
interconnections, such as die attach, while PC
MIN
is related also to the
chip-remote interconnections. Modeling can support the temperature
analysis during operations [16–18].
One important condition is related to the thermal interface material
(TIM). The TIM is placed between two mated surfaces of components
not attached with each other, e.g., module and its cooler. It serves
to reduce gaps, increasing the effective contact area and thermal con-
ductance at the interface. TIMs are used in transfer molded modules,
that are gaining attention in high power applications. In this context,
ACEPACK™ Surface Mounted Isolated Top-Side Cooled Package (SMIT),
represented in Fig. 1, is the test vehicle chosen in this study [19,20].
It is made up by automotive grade silicon (Si) MOSFETs, based on
super junction MDMesh technology [21]. This module encompasses
different possible types of implementable topologies: in this paper the
devices form a half bridge structure. The package is a top side cooling,
with a leadframe and a kelvin source pin. Moreover, it has a direct
bond copper substrate. ACEPACK™ SMIT is suitable for industrial and
automotive applications, such as on-board chargers.
This work compares power cycle performance of a power module
mounted on cooler using two different TIMs. The paper is organized in
the following way. In the next section, an overview of the TIM in power
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.microrel.2023.115162
Received 2 June 2023; Received in revised form 17 July 2023; Accepted 25 July 2023