© Riaño Yvonne and Wastl-Walter Doris, 2006:: „Historical Shifts in Asylum Policies in
Switzerland: Between Humanitarian Values and the Protection of National Identity”. Refugee
Watch, Issue No 27, Calcutta: A South Asian Journal on Forced Migration. Pp. 1- 18.
1
Historical Shifts in Asylum Policies in Switzerland: Between
Humanitarian Values and the Protection of National Identity
Yvonne Riaño and Doris Wastl-Walter
University of Bern, Switzerland
1
Abstract
As in many other European countries, the issue of asylum seeking has become in
Switzerland a central issue of public debate, and immigration and refugee
policies have become a top political priority. Pressure to make asylum policies
more restrictive has increasingly come from right-wing populist parties that have
become stronger over the past decade. This paper examines the shifts in policies
and state discourses of refugees in Switzerland from the end of the 19th century
up to today. The study is based on the perspective of critical discourse analysis,
“an approach that specifically focuses on the role of discourse in the reproduction
of power, dominance and inequality” (van Dijk, 2004: 20). The practical study of
state discourse focuses on three dimensions of analysis: the discourse itself, the
context of discourse, and the historical events surrounding the discourse. The
paper shows that the evolution of state representations of refugees in Switzerland
has evolved from a predominantly humanitarian attitude towards asylum-seekers
before the First World War to a mainly defensive attitude, which partly persists
today, where asylum-seekers are increasingly perceived as a cultural threat and a
financial burden. It demonstrates that imaginations of race, class and political
systems have been main factors in structuring shifting state representations of
refugees.
1 Introduction
One of the defining global issues of the early 21st century was the asylum for
refugees. Between 1980 and 2004, 9.9 million applications for asylum were
lodged in 39 countries in Europe, North America, Oceania and Asia. In 2004,
most claims were registered in Europe (444’000), followed by the Americas
(84’000), Africa (82’000), Asia and the Pacific (35’000). In Europe, the
countries with the largest numbers of applications were France (61’058), the
United Kingdom (40’202), Germany (35’613), Austria (24’676), Sweden
(23’161), Belgium (15’358) and Switzerland (14’248) (UNHCR, 2005a). The
issue of asylum seeking is currently one of the central challenges faced by
European states, and immigration and refugee policies have become a top
political priority. Pressure to make asylum policies more restrictive has