FULL PAPER
PPS
www.rsc.org/pps
Photocyclization of 2-vinyldiphenylacetylenes and behavior of the
isonaphthalene intermediates
Meledathu C. Sajimon and Frederick D. Lewis*
Department of Chemistry, Northwestern University, Evanston, IL, 60208-3113, USA.
E-mail: lewis@chem.northwestern.edu
Received 11th April 2005, Accepted 10th June 2005
First published as an Advance Article on the web 28th June 2005
The conformation, electronic structure, spectroscopy, and unimolecular photoisomerization of
2-vinyldiphenylacetylene and two derivatives have been investigated. 2-Vinyldiphenylacetylene exists predominantly
in a planar anti conformation. Introduction of an a-methyl substituent results in increased phenyl–vinyl dihedral
angles for both syn and anti conformers, whereas a cyclic analog is constrained to a syn conformation with a large
phenyl–vinyl dihedral angle. All three molecules undergo photocyclization to yield unstable cyclic allene
(isonaphthalene) intermediates which undergo further reactions leading to stable products. Both the photocyclization
process and behavior of the allene intermediate are dependent upon ground state conformation. The photophysical
behavior of the 2-vinyl derivative, namely its short singlet lifetime and low fluorescence quantum yield, is similar to
that of diphenylacetylene. It also has a low quantum yield for photocyclization. The 2-isopropenyl derivative and
conformationally locked cyclic analog have relatively long singlet lifetimes and large quantum yields for fluorescence
and cyclization. The difference in excited state behavior of the planar 2-vinylacetylene and its non-planar analogs is
attributed to the effect of the phenyl–vinyl dihedral angle on the barriers for activated decay of the linear singlet state.
However, the behavior of the 2-isopropenyl derivative does not appear to be dependent upon ground state
conformation (syn vs. anti). The cyclic allene intermediates undergo sequential protonation–deprotonation in
methanol solution to yield stable products. The 2-vinyl derivative yields only the fully aromatized
2-phenylnaphthalene. However, the 2-isopropenyl and cyclic derivatives yield mixtures of fully and partially
aromatized products. Preferential formation of the partially aromatized products is attributed to a stereoelectronic
effect on the deprotonation step. In diethyl ether solution only the fully aromatized product is formed via a free
radical mechanism.
Introduction
The behavior of the singlet excited states of diphenylacetylene
(DPA) has been the subject of continuing experimental and
theoretical investigation.
1–6
Much of the interest has centered
on its short-lived fluorescence, which has been attributed to an
upper singlet state. To briefly summarize the current state of
understanding, excitation of the linear ground state populates
a linear singlet state with quinoidal character (S
Q
) which
undergoes a low energy barrier crossing to a longer-lived dark
singlet state with stilbene-like geometry and diradical character
(S
t–S
, Scheme 1).
1,7
The fluorescence of DPA is assigned to
the short-lived S
Q
singlet state. This model accounts for the
pronounced excitation wavelength dependence and temperature
dependence of the fluorescence quantum yield and lifetime. The
Scheme 1
activation parameters for this barrier crossing, as determined
by Hirata et al. are E
a
= 2.5 kcal mol
−1
and log A = 12.8 in
hexane solution.
2
In comparison to the activation parameters for
the extensively investigated photoisomerization of trans-stilbene
(E
a
= 3.5 kcal mol
−1
, log A = 12.6) the activation energy is
somewhat smaller but the preexponentials are essentially the
same.
8
DPA has been reported to undergo a variety of photo-
chemical bimolecular addition reactions.
9–14
However, there
is but a single report of a unimolecular photoisomerization
reaction of a diphenylacetylene derivative: the conversion
of 2-vinyldiphenylacetylene (1) to 2-phenylnaphthalene (1a,
Scheme 2). This reaction was investigated by op den Brouw
and Laarhoven over two decades ago.
15
They proposed a two
stage mechanism: photocyclization to yield an unstable cyclic
allene (isonaphthalene) intermediate (1i) followed by thermal
isomerization to yield the observed product, which is obtained
in good preparative yield in either methanol or hexane solution
(Scheme 2). The regioselective incorporation of deuterium
upon irradiation in methanol-O-d was offered as evidence for
protonation–deprotonation, rather than the symmetry-allowed
intramolecular 1,5-hydrogen migration as the mechanism for
aromatization in methanol.
16,17
Scheme 2
DOI: 10.1039/b504997k
This journal is ©
The Royal Society of Chemistry and Owner Societies 2005 Photochem. Photobiol. Sci. , 2005, 4 , 629–636 629