Adsorption and Foaming Characteristics of Soy Globulins and
Tween 20 Mixed Systems
Victor Pizones Ruı ´z-Henestrosa, Cecilio Carrera Sa ´ nchez, and Juan M. Rodrı ´guez Patino*
Departamento de Ingenierı ´a Quı ´mica, Facultad de Quı ´mica, UniVersidad de SeVilla,
C/ Prof. Garcı ´a Gonza ´ lez, 1, E-41012-SeVilla (Spain)
The manufacture of food dispersions (emulsions and foams) with specific quality attributes depends on the
selection of the most appropriate raw materials and processing conditions. In this contribution, we have analyzed
the addition of Tween 20 (at 5 × 10
-6
and 1 × 10
-4
M, lower and higher than the critical micelle concentration,
CMC, respectively) to improve the dynamic interfacial characteristics (adsorption and surface dilatational
properties) and foam properties (foam capacity and stability) of soy globulin (7S and 11S at 0.1 wt %) acidic
aqueous solutions. We have observed that (i) the adsorption (presence of a lag period, diffusion, and penetration
at the air-water interface) of soy globulins depends on three factors: first the particular protein, second, the
level of association/dissociation of these proteins by varying the pH (pH 7 was included as a control), and,
finally, on the competitive adsorption between protein and Tween 20 in the aqueous phase. (ii) The surface
dilatational properties reflect the fact that soy globulin and Tween 20 adsorbed mixed films exhibit viscoelastic
behavior. The surface dilatational modulus decreases with the addition Tween 20 into the aqueous phase. (iii)
The rate of adsorption and surface dilatational properties (surface dilatational modulus and phase angle) during
adsorption at the air-water interface play an important role in the formation of foams generated from aqueous
solutions of soy globulins. However, the stability of the foam correlates with the properties of the film at
long-term adsorption.
Introduction
Foams are present in many foods, either in the finished
product or incorporated during the production as a preliminary
processing stage, which can be subjected to further processing
before the product is completed. Among the functional effect
of emulsifiers, foaming is of particular interest because it
provides the texture for many traditional (ice cream, whipped
topping, breads, cakes, meringues, beers, champagne, etc.) and
new (cheese, butter, spreads, confectionary, sausages, etc.)
aerated food products.
1-5
The positive benefits of aerated food
products are primarily to do with texture. However, foaming
may also create important problems during processing.
6,7
Thus,
knowledge of the mechanism of foam formation and stabiliza-
tion is essential if a foam of the required characteristics is to be
produced.
Foam formation and the stability of the resulting foam depend
on the properties of the surface active components in the
formulation.
6-16
Foam formation is influenced by the adsorption
of the foaming agent (emulsifier) at the air-water interface and
its ability to reduce surface tension and develop a mechanical
protection to new formed bubbles.
8-11,17
Stability is an important
property of food foams because consumer perception of quality
is influenced by appearance. Foams are thermodynamically
unstable, and their relative stability is affected by factors such
as drainage of liquid previously present in the foam, dispro-
portionation, and coalescence. Bubbles in a foam are stabilized
by a bilayer of emulsifier molecules separated by the continuous
aqueous phase. Thus, the characteristics of this thin film
determine the formation and stability of the foam.
9,17,15,17-20
An
important topic is how the macroscopic characteristics of a foam
can be improved by controlling the nanostructure formation at
fluid interfaces (molecular or interfacial engineering). Two types
of emulsifiers are used in foods:
2,21
low molecular weight
emulsifiers (mainly lipids, phospholipids, surfactants, etc.) and
macromolecules (proteins and some hydrocolloids). These
surface-active substances are used as foaming agents because
of their amphiphilic character.
In this work, we have analyzed how formulation engineering
can improve the interfacial and foaming characteristics of soy
globulin acidic aqueous solutions by the addition of a surfactant
(Tween 20). Vegetable proteins (i.e., soy globulins) are of
equivalent quality to those of meat, milk, and eggs, and their
production requires substantially fewer natural resources. The
popularity of these protein and peptide derivatives is increasing,
mainly because of their health benefits.
1,22,23
They are grouped
into two types according to their sedimentation coefficients,
-conglycinin (a 7S globulin) and glycinin (an 11S globulin).
A notable feature of soy proteins is the strong pH dependence
of the molecular conformation and the associated functional
properties.
24
Optimum functionality occurs at pH <5, which
limits their application as food ingredients. In fact, in many food
dispersion formulations emulsifiers (i.e., soy globulins) are used
in acidic aqueous solutions.
1,4,5,21,24
Thus, different strategies
have been used to improve soy globulin functionality by means
of the correlation between specific product property (foam
formation and stability) and interfacial properties (property
function), including the choice of suitable processing conditions,
such as pH, ionic strength, the addition of sucrose and Tween
20, and so forth.
25-27
Some surfactants (i.e., Tween 20) are used
as foaming agents in the food industry (i.e., in margarines, low-
fat spreads, baked products, creams and toppings, as a fat
substitute in low calorie foods,
28
etc.) in combination with
proteins to achieve positive synergistic effects on the charac-
teristics of the adsorbed film and foams.
29-34
Materials and Methods
Materials. Samples for interfacial characteristics of soy
protein films were prepared using Milli-Q ultrapure water and
* To whom correspondence should be addressed. Tel.: +34 95
4556446. Fax: +34 95 4556446. E-mail: jmrodri@us.es.
2876 Ind. Eng. Chem. Res. 2008, 47, 2876-2885
10.1021/ie071518f CCC: $40.75 © 2008 American Chemical Society
Published on Web 04/08/2008