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` a:8M EF;9B !"# %&'#( )* +,*#-#,.#/ b6 1< -/&< ,< +#c< WB X ]XVVX^< UW +01 23 ,?? #KLA?F; ?A :@<B 4, 5"# 6**#.578# 9)::&,7.;57), )* 5"# %#(&'5( )* 6:<7-7.;' =5&0#(/ >;-5 +/ d6 c!$%< ,< +#c< WUWW ]XVVb^ ]P.7 C@:FJ AD:A ?JKF8FC:@ I78G FL ;7I : NO;H:J?;A:@ K:8A 7N @?9:@ LCD7@:8LDFK R78H?8L 7; AD? R78F;9<T^]CFAF;9 !00e$ *3 !4< ,!= 0-/**,0B #4"+&-!, 0-/*,!+0/&")=/!. 0/*1,% =# 0.1%2 !$% /*= 0/*1,% =# 0.1%2 &.f dV ]XVVb^B ;8;7';?'# ;5 DAAK)__III<::@L<789_:JXVVb_K8798:J_NF;:@K8798:JJ:F;XVVb<KHN ]P.D?8? FL : @7;9 A8:HFAF7; 7N ?JKF8FC:@ LCD7@:8LDFK F; @:I :;H AD?8? D:L 8?C?;A@M R??; : RO89?7;F;9 7N F;A?8?LA F; C7;HOCAF;9 ?JKF8FC:@ 8?L?:8CD F; !J?8FC:eL @:I LCD77@L<T^^g (##/ #1@1/ 0.#3!$&# ,&$%h1&0. `3+!$E -+*00B 4#!01+&$a \1%&-&!, !-.&c&04 ]XVV6^g !;;: /:8Q?M ` i:88M 38F?HJ:;B A&.B7,@ !-)&?'#C 9),@-#((7),;''D +,0&.#0 =#'#.57), E7;( 7, 5"# =&<-#:# 9)&-5F( G@#,0;B \< *3 "*,0< d5j ]XVV6^g ":O@F;? EFJB A#'7?#-;57), ;,0 =5-;5#@D ), 5"# H,75#0 =5;5#( 9)&-5( )* G<<#;'(/ Wd5 1< "#$$< ,< +#c< WZW6 ]XVV6^1 UZ #KLA?F; ` EF;9B (&<-; ;7A? W<g a:8M EF;9B %#<'7.;57),/ %#<'7.;57),/ XU "0) "*,<0-&<`"*,< jjj ]W66d^< 85 Palmer: The Recusal of American Judges in the Post-Caperton Era Published by The Berkeley Electronic Press, 2010