Lipids (2016) 51:497–504
DOI 10.1007/s11745-016-4134-0
1 3
METHODS
The Use of Kits in the Analysis of Tissue Lipids Requires
Validation
T. Rider
1
· R. C. LeBoeuf
2
· Patrick Tso
3
· R. J. Jandacek
3
Received: 7 December 2015 / Accepted: 16 February 2016 / Published online: 7 March 2016
© AOCS 2016
Introduction
The measurement of the concentration of cholesterol,
phospholipids, and triacylglycerols in tissues is frequently
used to understand the metabolic effects of diet, pharma-
ceuticals, and genetics. In serum these classes of lipids are
readily analyzed by kits designed for concentrations that
are seen in blood. These kits, which utilize enzymatic reac-
tions, are convenient, fast, and efficient. Although these kits
are designed specifically for use in blood analyses, they are
used in the measurement of lipids in biological samples
other than serum (see, e.g., [1–4]).
As we demonstrate and discuss below, it may not be
assumed that the use of these kits for analyses of these
lipids in tissues is validated for measurement of lipids in all
tissues. There are several reasons that the kits may not be
applicable for use in all tissues. A potential source of error
in using the kits in tissue lipid analysis results from the
need to extract lipids from tissues to isolate them for analy-
sis. The dissolution/suspension of extracted lipid in a sol-
vent system that is compatible with the kit is then needed.
One may not assume that the uptake of lipid by this solu-
tion/suspension is complete since the extracted lipid may
exceed the capacity of the solvent system. Another poten-
tial source of error is the measurement of concentrations
of lipids that fall outside of the range found in serum, for
which the kits are designed. Also, in the case of cholesterol
measurement, the presence of triacylglycerol at relatively
high levels may interfere with the reactions and measure-
ment unless prior to analysis the sterols are isolated as the
non-saponifiable fraction of the lipids.
The purpose of this paper is to present evidence that the
validity of the kits for the analysis of tissue lipids may not
be assumed. We have not attempted to determine conditions
Abstract The ready availability and ease of use of kits
for the measurement of serum lipids has greatly facilitated
these measurements. In many cases it would be convenient
to use these kits in the determination of lipid concentrations
in tissues. The successful application of serum kits in tissue
analysis requires that two important issues be considered.
First, the solvent system for the extraction of the lipids and
the solvent used for analysis by the kit must be compat-
ible with the reactions in the kit. Second, the concentration
range in the analyzed solution must be within the range for
which the kit is used. We report here that lipids in liver and
adipose tissues may be significantly underestimated by the
use of some kits. We recommend that the use of kits for tis-
sue analysis of lipids be validated for the specific analysis.
Keywords Analytical biochemistry · Lipid analysis ·
Phospholipid analysis · Triglyceride analysis
Abbreviations
NIH National Institutes of Health
NIDDK National Institute of Diabetes and Digestion and
Kidney Disease
* Patrick Tso
Patrick.Tso@uc.edu
1
Department of Cancer Biology, University of Cincinnati,
Cincinnati, USA
2
Department of Medicine, University of Washington, Seattle,
USA
3
Department of Pathology and Laboratory Medicine,
University of Cincinnati, Cincinnati, USA