- The influence of managemenT hisTory on spaTial predicTion of Eryngium spinalba - 139
Applied Vegetation Science 11: 139-148, 2008
doi: 10.3170/2007-7-18337, published online 14 December 2007
© IAVS; Opulus Press Uppsala.
Abstract
Question: Spatial prediction of plant populations is essential
for conservation management. This is especially true for rare
and/or threatened endemic species, for which knowledge of
determinants of distribution is necessary to mitigate threats and
counteract decline. We therefore ask if the distribution of an
endemic species can be accurately predicted by georeferenced
environmental variables or, if anthropogenic variables also need
to be taken into account.
Location: Alps, Hautes-Alpes, France.
Methods: Potential distribution area and abundance of Eryngi-
um spinalba were predicted with logistic regression and ordinal
logistic regression, respectively, in a 57-km² watershed.
Results: Aspect, global solar radiation in March, elevation and
grazing pressure were the main predictors of the probability
of occurrence of Eryngium spinalba. Taking into account the
persistence of agro-pastoral activities by diachronic analysis
(Napoleonic cadastral map and orthorectifed photographs)
improved predictions from the model and the level of spatial
concordance with independent surveys.
Conclusions: Niche modelling improved our understanding of
the distribution of this threatened species which, in the context
of land abandonment, is diminishing as a result of the decline
of its favoured habitats. The key role of pastoral activities
and historic continuity for its distribution and persistence was
clearly demonstrated.
Keywords: Calcareous grassland; Conservation management;
Endemism; Geographical Information System; Grazing; Land
abandonment; Spatial modelling.
Abbreviations: AIC = Akaike’s information criterion; AUC
= Area under the curve; CBNA = Conservatoire Botanique
National Alpin; DEM = Digital elevation model; GLM =
Generalized linear model ; LP = Linear predictor; LRM = Lo-
gistic regression model ; PET = Potential evapotranspiration;
PHDM = Potential habitat distribution map; ROC = Receiver
operating characteristic; UGB = Stocking equivalent of one
adult bovine.
Nomenclature: Kerguélen & Brisse (1994).
The infuence of management history on spatial prediction of
Eryngium spinalba, an endangered endemic species
Marage, Damien
1*
; Garraud, Luc
2
& Rameau, Jean-Claude(†)
1
AgroParisTech, UMR1092 Laboratoire d’étude des Ressources Forêt-Bois (LERFoB), 14 rue Girardet, CS 4216 F-54000
Nancy, France;
2
Conservatoire Botanique National Alpin de Gap-Charance, Domaine de Charance, 05 000 Gap, France;
E-mail l.garraud@cbn-alpin.org;
*
Corresponding author; Fax +33 383396878; E-mail damien.marage@agroparistech.fr
Introduction
The distribution of plant species in terrestrial eco-
systems is infuenced by climatic, physiographic and
geological factors which are all part of a natural or an-
thropogenic regime that structures these ecosystems in
space and time. Distributions are, therefore, the results
of complex processes in a hierarchical continuum (Allen
& Starr 1982). Many ecological studies have considered
plant species distributions both in environmental and
geographical space (Brown 1994; Guisan et al. 1998;
Zimmermann & Kienast 1999), in which the fundamental
niche of a species can be defned as the range of envi-
ronmental conditions where a species may persist over
time, i.e. complete a full life cycle (Austin & Smith 1989;
Austin & Gaywood 1994). Interspecifc interactions such
as competition and facilitation may reduce or increase
the fundamental niche so that the realised niche (Grubb
1977) differs from the fundamental niche.
Static modelling of species distributions (Guisan &
Zimmerman 2000) aims to link the species distributional
area to the environmental variables that best defne the
realized niche. Many such studies have been conducted
(Richerson & Lum 1980; Lenihan 1993; Beerling et
al. 1995; Huntley et al. 1995; Guisan et al. 1998; Zim-
mermann & Kienast 1999; Collingham et al. 2000), and
niche modelling is becoming an increasingly important
tool for biodiversity management (Lehmann et al. 2002).
In Europe, Zimmermann & Kienast (1999) and Guisan et
al. (1998) have modelled distributions of Alpine plants
using logistic regressions, but niche modelling has
not been used in the Mediterranean mountains where
anthropogenic infuences are assumed to play a crucial
role for plant distributions (Douguedroit 1976; Blondel
& Arroson 1995; Reille et al. 1996).
Archaeological data and paleo-environmental re-
search (Reille et al. 1996; Lopez-Saez et al. 2001) have
documented that Mediterranean mountains have been
used by humans for a long time (Roberts et al. 2001). For
ca. 7000 years, plant communities of these mountains
have been profoundly affected by anthropogenic impacts.
The intensity and duration of human activities, including