978-1-7281-7312-2/20/$31.00 ©2020 IEEE
Design and Optimization of Sparse Planar Antenna
Arrays Based on Special Matrices
Yiyang Luo
Department of theoretical radiophysics
V. N. Karazin Kharkiv National
University
Kharkiv, Ukraine
yiyangluo@163.com
Vladislav Lusenko
Department of Radiophysicintroscopy
O. Ya. Usikov Institute for
Radiophysics and Electronics of NASU
Kharkiv, Ukraine
lutsenko@ire.kharkov.ua
Sergey Shulga
Department of theoretical radiophysics
V. N. Karazin Kharkiv National
University
Kharkiv, Ukraine
sergeyshulga@karazin.ua
Abstract— As sparse arrays can cover a large space with
relatively few elements, their low cost and undegraded radiation
patterns have attracted more and more interest. And also due to
the randomness of antenna locations, sparse arrays can avoid
the generation of grating lobes while the spacing between
adjacent antenna is greater than half a wavelength. However,
the locations of the antenna need to be carefully considered to
ensure its acceptable level of performance. And Formally, the
design of sparse arrays can be expressed as a constrained
multidimensional nonlinear optimization problem. However,
due to the lack of convexity, using deterministic optimization
methods to solve this kind of multi-extremity problem is very
tricky, and non-deterministic optimization methods (such as
iterative methods) that are very time-consuming and wasteful of
resources are always used to solve the problem. In this work, a
simple and time-saving method for designing a two-dimensional
planar antenna array using a deterministic method based on
special matrices (including, Magic square, Latin square, and
triangular matrix) are proposed. And the detailed design
process, MATLAB simulation verification and comparative
analysis are presented in the paper.
Keywords—antenna design, latin square, magic square,,
MATLAB simulation, radiation pattern, sparse planar antenna
arrays, spatial frequencies, triangular matrix.
I. INTRODUCTION
Compared with the limited directivity of a single antenna,
the antenna array can be widely used in various occasions,
including telecommunication, wireless 3D local positioning
system, and radio astronomy. And also antenna arrays have
the potential to meet the stringent requirements on the
multibeam, multichannel, and beam reconfigurability in many
communication, sensor, and radar systems. However, the
trade-off between the desired accuracy and a minimal antenna
element number filling the antenna aperture needs to be
considered in the design of an antenna array in order to reduce
the electronic beamforming cost, the power consumption, and
overall design complexity.
The aperiodic arrays introduced by Unz [1] may meet the
above requirements. Usually, the Sparse Array approach and
the Thinned Array approach used to design such arrays.
Unlike the Thinned Array approach, where the optimization
starts from a densely filled regular array, after which some
elements are removed to obtain an aperiodic array layout
while meeting certain specifications [2], the Sparse Array
approach directly positions the minimum antenna elements
optimally based on specific criteria [3]. And several ways of
implementing these approaches have been proposed, which
are based on analytical (Almost Difference Sets [3], Matric
Pencil Method [4]), stochastic (Genetic Algorithms [5]), or
deterministic methods (Taylor Taper [6]). Each of these
methods has advantages and disadvantages and has its own
unique scope of application. However, no matter which
method is used, there are two aspects to consider array design:
1) According to different mission objectives, the antenna
needs to achieve specific requirements in specific occasions,
and at the same time, it needs to consider actual various cost
issues and the balance of different parameters, such as,
mainlode beamwidth (MBW), sidelobe level (SLL), the
number of elements, calculating time etc. Antenna array
design is actually a multi-dimensional nonlinear optimization
problem. Unfortunately, there are no closed solutions [7]. And
usually, this kind of multiextremal problem is difficult to solve
due to lack of convexity.
2) The essence of the antenna array is a combination of
different antenna units, which cannot be separated from the
electromagnetic (EM) field characteristics of the antenna itself.
And especially when there are non-negligible obstacles
around the antenna (even indoors), and the signal source, echo
and interference have to be considered. Moreover, effects like
antenna feeding and mutual coupling (MC) that degrade
antenna array performance should be taken into account in the
array design. Considering the scenario used by our array,
when analyzing the radiation pattern, the near-field effect or
the far-field according to the distance between the antenna and
the target also need to be considered. In turn, the
electromagnetic field characteristics of the antenna itself also
can be used to help design the antenna arrays to solve specific
practical physical problems. Specific constraints will make
our design problems more specific, and provide more
conditions to solve the problem.
For the authors, the issues considered are more inclined to
the region of astronomical radio, the measured signals are
from distant celestial bodies, the near-field effect is not
considered, and the antenna array used is an array composed
of sub-arrays of a large enough array aperture. The distance
between each antenna element is greater than half of the
wavelength, and the MC effect can be ignored. Because the
signals from distant stars are weak and sensitive, the device
needs to have higher sensitivity and lower interference, that is,
an antenna array with a possible large physical size and a low
side lobe level. And if possible, the array is as sparse as
possible to reduce energy consumption and the system's own
interference with the measurement. At the same time, it is
necessary to ensure that the spatial frequency of the array is
completely covered to reduce unwanted grading lobe and
unpredictable side lobe [8].
Based on the above constraints, a method for directly
designing sparse arrays with some mathematical concepts was
proposed, which is simple and efficient. Unlike global
optimization (GO), this is a design method that uses the
physical properties of the antenna and combines the
__________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
2020 IEEE Ukrainian Microwave Week
Kharkiv, Ukraine, September 21 - 25
79