Natural Sciences Education • Volume 46 • 2017 1 of 10
uNdErGraduatE EducatioN
Blending Multimedia and Face-to-Face Teaching to Enhance
Learning about the Forest Floor
Darrell Hoffman,* Maja Krzic, Samson Nashon, and Margaret Schmidt
abstract
The forest floor is essential to functional, healthy forests.
It is important for forestry professionals to understand,
describe, and classify forest floors. We developed a Forest
Floor educational resource, blending web-based multimedia
and face-to-face teaching. The objectives of this study were
to (1) develop blended-learning activities to teach forest floor
description and classification and (2) assess student perceptions
of the blended-learning method using exploratory factor
analysis and group interviews. We used a Likert scale survey
instrument to assess student perceptions of their learning, and
investigated underlying factors through exploratory factor
analysis of survey results and the manifestation of factors in
focus group interviews. Five implicit factors were interpreted:
(1) satisfaction with the Forest Floor resource as a learning
enhancement; (2) response to presentation of concepts using
a blended learning method; (3) student self-assessment of
learning; (4) student learning preferences in accessing materials;
and (5) website usability. Ninety-four percent of students
agreed or strongly agreed that the Forest Floor resource was
helpful for learning forest floor concepts, 79% that describing
samples in class was essential for understanding the properties
of organic horizons, and 81% that they were able to relate
information in the Forest Floor resource to samples used in
a face-to face activity, demonstrating that students tended to
prefer learning information from videos and in collaboration
with other students, and felt positive about their knowledge of
the new material.
D. Hoffman, Northern Forestry Centre, Carbon Accounting Team,
5320 122 Street, Edmonton, AB T6H 3S5, Canada; M. Krzic, Univ. of
British Columbia, 2357 Main Mall, Vancouver, BC V6T 1Z4, Canada; S.
Nashon, Dep. of Curriculum and Pedagogy, Univ. of British Columbia,
2125 Main Mall, Vancouver, BC V6T 1Z4; M. Schmidt, Dep. of
Geography, Simon Fraser Univ., 8888 University Dr., Burnaby, BC V5A
1S6, Canada. *Corresponding author (darrell.r.hoffman@gmail.com).
Abbreviations: CFA, confirmatory factor analysis; CMS, content
management system; EFA, exploratory factor analysis; ESL, English
as second language; KMO, Kaiser-Myer-Olkin (Test of Sampling
Adequacy); PAF, principal axis factoring; PCA, principal component
analysis; UBC, University of British Columbia.
Published in Nat. Sci. Educ. 46:170008 (2017)
doi:10.4195/nse2017.05.0008
Received 6 May 2017
Accepted 28 June 2017
Copyright © 2017 by the American Society of Agronomy
5585 Guilford Road, Madison, WI 53711 USA
All rights reserved
core ideas
• Forest floor is essential to forest ecosystems, but classification is
difficult.
• Multimedia and face-to-face learning can teach visual tasks like
soil classification.
• Students identified repeated visualizations and collaboration as
important.
• Combining quantitative and qualitative methods of assessment
gives deeper insights.
T
he forest floor is one of the most distinctive parts of
a forest ecosystem. It is composed of various veg-
etative parts (leaves, twigs, branches, bark, etc.)
that are present at the soil surface and in various stages
of decomposition. The forest floor is characterized by a
great diversity of soil organisms and it plays an important
role in carbon storage, nutrient cycling, and water reten-
tion. Although forest floor is reflective of overall forest site
quality (Klinka et al., 1981), biodiversity, nutrient supply
capability, and soil productivity (Ponge and Chevalier, 2006),
learning about forest floor is not often part of university
curriculum where the number of soil science courses is
decreasing (Collins, 2008) or where soil science is becoming
a required component of more generalized, integrative pro-
grams (Hansen et al., 2007). Because most post-secondary
forestry programs still require at least an Introduction to
Soil Science course (Collins, 2008), it is important that this
course covers basic forest floor concepts and its role as a
bridge between the aboveground, living vegetation and the
soil. Repeated visualizations and hands-on experience are
essential for learning about forest floor, and these can be
addressed by a blended learning approach.
The present generation of post-secondary students has
grown up with information and communication technology,
and they handle digital information on a daily basis. They
are connected to each other via mobile technologies,
work interactively, and often perform several tasks
simultaneously (Tapscott, 2008). According to Prensky
(2001) and van Eck (2006), increased disengagement
of the so-called “net generation” or “digital natives” from
traditional instruction together with the ongoing popularity
of digital technology have prompted interest in blended
learning at both secondary and post-secondary levels.
Blended learning involves integration of computer-mediated
learning with face-to-face teaching (Owston et al., 2013).
It has generally been thought that blended learning is more
effective than face-to-face or online learning alone (Means
et al., 2010), improving student satisfaction (Castle and
McGuire, 2010) and grades (Cavanagh, 2011). Success
of blended learning, however, depends on its integration
Published online August 10, 2017