Wear 261 (2006) 367–381
Progression of wear in the mild wear regime of an
Al-18.5% Si (A390) alloy
M. Elmadagli, A.T. Alpas
∗
NSERC/General Motors of Canada Industrial Research Chair in Tribology of Lightweight Materials, Department of Mechanical,
Automotive and Materials Engineering, University of Windsor, 401 Sunset Avenue, Windsor, Ont., Canada N9B 3P4
Received 30 June 2005; received in revised form 8 November 2005; accepted 18 November 2005
Available online 18 January 2006
Abstract
The mild wear regime of a cast Al-18.5% Si (A390), a lightweight alloy used in automotive components requiring wear resistance, was investigated
in order to characterize the progression of the sliding wear processes. Block-on-ring (SAE 52100 steel) type sliding wear tests were conducted
under a controlled dry air environment with 5% relative humidity. It was observed that the mild wear regime consisted of two sub-regimes: The
first sub-regime of mild wear (MW-1) occurred at loads between 0.2 N and 35 N, and the second sub-regime of mild wear (MW-2) between 60 N
and 150N. A common characteristic of MW-1 and MW-2 was the attainment of steady-state wear conditions. The load (L) dependence of the
steady-state wear rates (W) in both sub-regimes was expressed as W = C(L)
n
, where C
1
= 1.08 × 10
-4
, n
1
= 0.56 for MW-1 and C
2
= 2.18 × 10
-4
,
n
2
= 0.67 for MW-2. A transition regime, where the wear rates of MW-1 increased by 270%, occurred in the 35–60 N load range. The transition
between MW-1 and MW-2 was accompanied by a rapid increase (25%) in the amount of material transferred to the counterface.
Sliding wear in both sub-regimes proceeded by the formation of tribolayers that were initiated by iron transfer from the steel counterface to
the silicon particles on the contact surfaces. Compared to MW-1, tribolayers were formed at a faster rate in MW-2 and the amount of material
transferred to the counterface was larger. Also, in MW-2 the magnitudes of plastic strains (ε) in the deformed aluminum subsurfaces below the
tribolayers were higher, e.g., at 40 m below the surface ε = 3 at 60 N, compared to ε = 0.1 at 10 N at the same depth. In addition, in MW-2, both
the tribolayers and the material transferred to the counterface contained layers of aluminum, implying that the aluminum matrix became in contact
with the counterface. Spallation of thick tribolayers formed in MW-2 as well as extrusion of exposed aluminum surfaces over the tribolayers were
among the main reasons for the higher wear rates in this regime compared to MW-1.
© 2005 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
Keywords: Al–Si alloys; Dry sliding; Wear mechanisms; Wear regimes; Tribolayers; Material transfer; Subsurface deformation
1. Introduction
Because of their technological significance as lightweight
alternatives to the traditional use of cast iron in automotive com-
ponents, sliding wear behaviour of cast Al–Si alloys has been the
subject of a large number of laboratory scale studies. Sarkar’s
[1] work on a near eutectic Al-11% Si alloy and a hypereutectic
Al-22% Si alloy tested against grey iron pins and the pin-on-disc
tests by Shivanath et al. [2] on binary Al–Si alloy pins (4–20%
Si) against steel discs (1% C–1.5% Cr) are among the early
studies that have been often cited. These studies performed in
late 1970s have shown that two distinct wear regimes occurred
∗
Corresponding author. Tel.: +1 519 253 3000x2602; fax: +1 519 973 7085.
E-mail address: aalpas@uwindsor.ca (A.T. Alpas).
during dry sliding of Al–Si alloys against iron based counter-
faces, namely (i) a mild wear regime, which was characterized
by low wear rates (10
-4
mm
3
/m to 10
-3
mm
3
/m) accompanied
by formation of oxidized tribolayers on the contact surfaces and
(ii) a severe wear regime that existed at high loads and test
speeds, and was sometimes described as metallic wear due to
the shiny appearance of severely deformed contact surfaces. The
observations summarized by Eyre [3] are typical of these early
studies. In the mild wear, the worn surfaces were covered by
dark compacted oxide layers, presumed to consist of a mixture
of aluminum oxide and some transferred iron. The severe wear
was accompanied by the transfer of aluminum to the counter-
face. Wear rates in the severe wear regime were usually one order
of magnitude higher than those in the mild wear. Razavizadeh
and Eyre [4,5] examined the oxidative wear mechanism during
the sliding wear of Al-16% Si alloy pins tested against a steel
0043-1648/$ – see front matter © 2005 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.wear.2005.11.006