Precision Engineering 42 (2015) 346–351
Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Precision Engineering
jo ur nal homep age: www.elsevier.com/locate/precision
Technical note
Entangled structures as high cycle compression springs
Folkers E. Rojas
∗
, Alexander H. Slocum
Department of Mechanical Engineering, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, MA 02139, USA
a r t i c l e i n f o
Article history:
Received 2 February 2015
Accepted 20 April 2015
Available online 27 May 2015
Keywords:
Entangled structures
Foams
Fibrous metals
Springs
a b s t r a c t
Entangled structures, such as steel wool, can be used as inexpensive, high cycle, low stiffness, thin profile
compressive springs where uniform pressure on a surface is required particularly in elevated temperature
and/or harsh environments. Mechanical compression tests were performed on a variety of steel wool sam-
ples to determine the stress–strain curve behavior over high cycles. After initial conditioning cycles, good
repeatability can be obtained with hysteresis dependent on strain. The results show a nonlinear behavior
over large strains (>10%) and reasonable linear behavior for strains less than 10%. The properties of an
entangled structure spring can be selected to achieve the desired stiffness for a particular application.
© 2015 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
1. Introduction
The mechanics of a random array of interwoven fibers, i.e. entan-
gled wires such as found in steel wool, have been studied for
applications such as damping, isolating, or filtering. In semiconduc-
tor test applications “Fuzz Buttons,” a compacted random array of
wire, have been used as temporary electrical contacts for “low sig-
nal distortion, high frequency, and low insertion force, planarity,
and shock/vibration resistance” [1]. Contact testers made from
micro entangled structures have been used by the semi-conductor
industry to test Through Silicon Via (TSV) and micro-bumps arrays
[2,3]. The characterization of entangled wires is also very important
for micro-electronics, micro fluidics, micro sensors and actuators
that are based on entangled silica nano-wire structures [4]. The
generation of the silica nanowire entangled arrays are grown, and
not created via a mechanical means and they often appear as entan-
gled [4,5]. Entangled structures are also used by the space industry
to isolate instruments or to damp vibrations [6,7].
Entangled structures have also been evaluated as compati-
ble replacements for porous aluminum as they have been shown
to have good toughness and strength [8,9]. Entangled titanium
wire materials (ETWM) and porous titanium foams have been
considered for tissue reconstruction, orthopedic implants, and
bone repairs [10–14]. The challenge for the medical industry
has been to match the mechanical properties of entangled wire
structures to similar mechanical properties of bone which has
been attempted by altering the effective porosity of the structure
∗
Corresponding author. Tel.: +1 603 513 8997; fax: +1 603 225 3102.
E-mail address: Folkers.Rojas@gmail.com (F.E. Rojas).
created by the entangled wires [11,14]. While compressive
properties and pseudo-elastic hysteresis behaviors have been char-
acterized for ETWMs, a high cycle analysis of the nonlinear elastic
region of ETWMs is needed to make the design process more deter-
ministic.
Prior work has shown that entangled structures have a
three-stage stress–strain behavior under compressive loads: (1)
nonlinear elastic deformation, (2) strain-hardening, and (3) den-
sifying [10]. Here we build on this work by studying the higher
cycle compliance of entangled structures under uniaxial compres-
sion for the use as an inexpensive and repeatable low-moderate
stiffness thin profile large contact area spring. This type of spring
has wide application in presses and rectilinear format batteries.
This work also examines the effect of densification on the appar-
ent Young’s modulus for entangled structures for comparison with
existing analytical models. Analogies are made with low density
materials such as foams, composites, and elastomers in order to
help develop modeling tools.
2. Experimental procedures
2.1. Sample characterization
One method for generating an entangled metal wire structure
involves wrapping the wire around a rod to create a loose steel
wire bundle. The unconsolidated deformed wire is placed into a set
of molds where it is compressed and sintered to remove internal
stresses [8,10,15]. Common steel wool, which is much more compli-
ant and inexpensive, is made by shaving small strands from straight
steel wire and consolidating the strands into an entangled struc-
ture using a needle punch machine to generate a mat of wool. The
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.precisioneng.2015.04.013
0141-6359/© 2015 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.