Tis copy for personal use only – distribution prohibited
Tis copy for personal use only – distribution prohibited — Tis copy for personal use only – distribution prohibited
Electronic PDF security by Committe of Scientifc Research, Stowarzyszenie Idokan Polska Poland
PHILOSOPHY / ETHICS
Wojciech J. Cynarski
Chair of Cultural Foundations of Physical Education, Sport and Recreation,
Faculty of Physical Education, University of Rzeszów, Rzeszów (Poland)
e-mail: ela_cyn@wp.pl
Moral values, and the people of the noble way of martial arts
Submission: 13.07.2013; acceptance: 1.12.2013
Key words: martial arts, ethics, moral ways, Christianity, nobility
Abstract:
Te aim of this study is to conduct a critical analysis of the ethics functioning in selected systems of martial arts. Te theoretical
perspective is based on the humanistic theory of martial arts, and the sociology and anthropology of martial arts.
Te main method of research is a content analysis of documents and specialised literature, which is complemented by a qualitative
method i.e. the author’s long-time participant observation of the international martial arts environment.
In terms of a diachronic and synchronic approach, old traditions of martial arts, Christian infuences in the area and the question
of what their ethos looks like today are consecutively analysed.
Tanks to Christian axiology the ethos of chivalry seems to be a unique achievement of historical warrior culture. Te philosophy of
idō is presented in an interesting way, as a result of the specifc synergies between the ideas of East Asian martial arts and European
knighthood. In contrast, the contemporary budō includes an axiological canon, which today manifests itself in various ways. Tis
is particularly true of the multiform world of martial arts.
© Idōkan Poland Association
“IDO MOVEMENT FOR CULTURE. Journal of Martial Arts Anthropology”,
Vol. 14, no. 1 (2014), pp. 1–10
Introduction
From the perspective of the humanistic theory of
martial arts and the anthropology of the warrior’s
way [Cynarski 2004a, 2012; Obodyński 2009] we
shall undertake a discussion of the moral values
of martial arts, in the past and now. We shall begin
with historiosophical considerations and the theory
of civilization. Te issues of ethics, especially the
chivalric ethos, will be the “common denominator”
for further discussion. Subsequent fragments will be
dedicated to the ancient traditions of martial arts,
Christian infuences in the area and the question
of how the contemporary ethos preserves these
and other values. If for the purpose of interpreting
the complex, contemporary socio-cultural reality
a multidimensional anthropological, ethical and
educational perspective is assumed [Szmyd 2011],
the same should apply to this interpretation of
current codes of chivalry and their derivatives.
Te philosophy of the martial arts has already
been discussed by several authors. Tey were former
warriors and sages, such as Miyamoto Musashi,
[1983] or Yagyu Munenori [2002]. However, they
focused more on the philosophy of combat and
the preparation of a warrior for a “life-and-death”
confrontation. Today, experts and philosophers
among others, describe the ethics of martial arts,
relating them to the place of origin of the Chinese,
Japanese or Korean martial arts and the historically
dominant axio-normative systems there [cf. Jazarin
1960; Tokarski 1989; Carr 1993; Saldern 1993;
Maroteaux 1995; Kim, Bäck 2000].
In the subject literature we do indeed fnd
publications concerning the application of the
educational paths of martial arts: self-improvement
and self-realization, self-control and self-discipline,
etc. [Kanō 1932; Wolters 2005; Baka 2008]. At
the same time the teaching of martial arts refers
to various philosophical, religious or mystical
traditions. Some perceive the source of spirituality
in the canon of Zen Buddhism [Hof 1998; Lind
1998; Wolters 2005] others, probably rightly, in
diferent traditions of spirituality [Oyama 1979;
Maliszewski 1996; Pietrzak, Cynarski 2000;
Cynarski 2001]. Martial arts experts who are also
teachers, emphasize the universal values of teaching
martial arts (as educational systems) [Kanō 1932;