Psychological Medicine, 1993, 23, 745-753. Copyright © 1993 Cambridge University Press
Symptom dimensions and cognitive and social
functioning in recent-onset schizophrenia
A. J. W. VAN DER DOES,
1
P. M. A. J. DINGEMANS, D. H. LINSZEN, M. A. NUGTER
AND W. F. SCHOLTE
From the Department of Psychiatry, Leiden University; Department of Psychiatry, University of Amsterdam;
Institute for Psychotherapy 'De Oosthoek', Limmen, The Netherlands
SYNOPSIS The relationships among symptoms, cognitive functioning and social functioning were
investigated in 60 patients with recent-onset schizophrenia. Positive symptoms were unrelated to
cognitive measures. Disorganization and depressive symptoms were correlated significantly with
Card Sorting performance. Furthermore, only negative symptoms were correlated significantly with
social functioning. These results replicate earlier studies with chronic and mixed samples, and
support the validity of disorganization as a separate symptom dimension. In contrast to most
previous studies, no significant correlations were found between negative symptoms and cognitive
measures. However, some evidence was found for a non-linear association between negative
symptoms and several cognitive measures. The variation explained by a curvilinear model was not
high, but for some cognitive measures this model was clearly superior to a linear model. If
replicated, this finding supports the position that cross-sectionally measured negative symptoms
cannot be viewed as a unitary concept.
INTRODUCTION
In the past decade supporting evidence has
become available for the validity of the so-called
type I/type II model of schizophrenia, but the
need for refinement of the model has also
become apparent. In the type I/type II model,
two major syndromes of schizophrenia are
postulated, each with a specific pathophysiology,
course and response to treatment (Crow, 1980).
The syndromes can be recognized by clinical
presentation (predominance of positive or nega-
tive symptoms). Although biological research
has yielded mixed results (e.g. Andreasen &
Olsen, 1982; Andreasen et al. 1990), studies
have indicated that negative symptoms are a
common and valid component of schizophrenia,
and that they are related to poor pre-morbid
functioning and poor long-term outcome when
present beyond the early phase of illness
(McGlashan & Fenton, 1992). Research has also
shown a relationship between negative symp-
• Address for correspondence: Dr A. J. W. Van der Does, Leiden
University, Department of Psychiatry, Jelgersma Polikliniek, PO
Box 1251, 2340 BG Oegstgeest, The Netherlands.
toms and cognitive impairment (e.g. Andreasen
et al. 1990; Addington et al. 1991; Schwartz et
al. 1991). Recently, however, the type I/type II
model has been challenged by Liddle (1987a),
who factor-analysed schizophrenic symptoms
and concluded that these segregate into three
dimensions, with a disorganization factor be-
sides a positive and negative symptom factor.
This three-dimensional structure has since been
replicated with different symptom scales and in
different samples (Liddle & Barnes, 1990; Arndt
et al. 1991; Van der Does et al. 1993). There are
indications that these three symptom dimensions
have distinctive patterns of relationships with
other variables, for instance neurological signs
and cognitive test performance (e.g. Liddle,
19876; Kay, 1990; Liddle & Morris, 1991).
The studies by Liddle and co-workers have
been with chronic patients only and with rather
small sample sizes. The present study was
designed to investigate the relationships among
symptom dimensions, cognitive and social func-
tioning in a homogeneous sample of young,
recent-onset schizophrenic patients. In a pre-
vious report (Van der Does et al. 1993), a four-
dimensional model of symptoms was found with
745