Copyright © IFA C Artificial Inte lli gence.
Leningrad. US SR 1 9R3
!
ON A COMPUTER-ORIENTED FORMALIZATION OF
PLAUSIBLE REASONING IN F. BACON-J. S. MILL'S STYLE
(MAIN PRINCIPLES AND COMPUTER EXPERIMENTS)
V. K. Finn, M. I. Zabezhailo and O. M. Anshakov
A ll Ullio ll Ill stitllle of Scientific alld Technical Inf ormation, VINIT!, M OSCO II ', USS R
Abstract. The paper generalizes the problems of creation the
solvers of some special types. The computer-aided formaliza-
tion of inductive approaches of F.Bacon-J.S.Mill is proposed.
The experiments with computer-orientation are discussed •
.,.
Keywords. Inductive inference; inductive reasoning; correlati-
.,,:·on theory; empirical dependence; plausible reasoning.
1. Artifitial Intelligence may be
considered to be a discipline,which
creates and studies computer-orient-
ed formal means of simulating man's
cognitive activity. naturally, it
would be desirable for this simula-
tion to contain both a sensor model
of the external world's perception
and a model of a reasoning individu-
al. This individual sould be able to
combine sensor data and stored know-
ledge in order to apply logical pro-
cedures of data processing for making
appropriate decisions.
It follows from the above, that an
investigation of different types of
reasonings (both in theoretical, and
in applied aspects - from the view-
point of an effectivity of their si-
mulation on a computer is a fundamen-
tal problem of Artifitial Intelligen-
ce. This problem is included in the
variety of problems, which may be
called "computer epistemology". The
term "reasoning" may be understood
as: reasoning = heuretic + deduction.
In this sense reasoning is connected
with the simulation of mentality:
heuretic (formally described) is si-
mulation of fragments of intuition
while deduction is a systematical
formulation of heuretic results (con-
clusions from hypotheses, obtaining
of consequences including those,that
are in contradiction with given data
or, conversely those that confirm
automatically created hypotheses
etc.). Successes and difficulties of
deduction's realization on computers
3 51
are well kno\vn. The simulation purely
heuristic procedures, including em-
pirical induction, is less advanced
(both in theoretical, and practical
respects). The concept of "heuretic"
may be approximated by a system of
plausible inference rules with dif-
ferent organizations (strategies).
!n this paper an approach to the for-
malization of heuristic reasoning of
the type is examined, i.e. that with
data containing incomplete informa-
tion, hence, requiring the use of ma-
ny-valued (non-classical) logics as
a means of formalization. Let Vdes be
a set of designated truth-values,
V
undes
- a set of undesignated truth-
-values, Val-function of valuation;
cp,. .,., <Pit, 1.p,j( - formulas of the lo-
gics involved. Inference rule R will
be called "plausible inference rule"
(p.i.r.) if there are such CPf, · .· CPIt, If/"
that 'P{, ... rpll f-;[ VI', VQl(Y',)E V<::Je$
and Va.{ C 1.p) E V undes' but the num-
ber of such cases is sufficiently
small.
Let r be some set of formulas in
the language of first-order predicate
logic, CPCa,)is CP(X./Qi)' i=1, ••• ,n,
then: